About Me

My photo
since 1985 practicing as advocate in both civil & criminal laws. This blog is only for information but not for legal opinions

Friday, March 5, 2021

levying GST on the value of broken rice, bran and husk obtained by the petitioners on custom milling of the paddy.= the assessment orders passed by the 1st respondent levying GST on the value of by-products i.e., broken rice, bran and husk treating them as part of the consideration paid to the petitioners for custom milling of the paddy, are set aside.

levying GST on the value of broken rice, bran and husk obtained by the petitioners on custom milling of the paddy.= the assessment orders  passed by the 1st respondent levying GST on the value of by-products i.e., broken rice, bran and husk treating them as part of the consideration paid to the petitioners for custom milling of the paddy, are set aside.

AP HIGH COURT

 HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE U. DURGA PRASAD RAO

AND

HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE J. UMA DEVI

Writ Petition Nos.3108, 3114 of 2020 & 3970, 3980 and

3988 of 2021

M/S SRI KALI PRASADBABU RICE TRADERS

-VERSES-

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER

COMMON ORDER: (per UDPR,J)


 These batch of writ petitions are filed challenging the

assessment orders passed by the 1st respondent levying GST on the

value of broken rice, bran and husk obtained by the petitioners on

custom milling of the paddy.

2. Heard learned counsel for petitioners, Sri G. Narendra Chetty,

learned Government Pleader for Commercial Tax representing on

behalf of respondent Nos.1 and 2, Sri P.Hema Chandra, learned

standing counsel representing on behalf of respondent No.3 and

learned Assistant Solicitor General of India representing on behalf of

respondent No.4.

3. When the matter is taken up for hearing, learned counsel for

petitioners would submit that the subject matter in these writ petitions

is squarely covered by the order passed by this Court in

W.P.No.45971 of 2018, dated 20.11.2020 and the same order may be

passed in these writ petitions also. Learned Government Pleader for

Commercial Tax representing on behalf of respondents has not

disputed the said fact.

4. Following the above said order and for the reasons recorded

therein, these writ petitions are also allowed and the assessment orders 

2

passed by the 1st respondent levying GST on the value of

by-products i.e., broken rice, bran and husk treating them as part of

the consideration paid to the petitioners for custom milling of the

paddy, are set aside. However, it is made clear that the petitioners are

liable to pay tax on sale of by-products if they are statutorily taxable.

 As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending for

consideration, if any, shall stand closed. No costs.

_________________________

U.DURGA PRASAD RAO, J

_______________

J.UMA DEVI, J

Dt:19.02.2021

 MS 

whether family members of misssing employee can claim family pension etc., ? her husband, who was missing for last seven years, may be deemed not to be alive, the respondent approached the petitioners for grant of terminal benefits, pension/family pension etc.= the scope of grant of retiral benefits to family members of a missing employee as provided in OM No.F.No.1/17/2011-P&PW(E), dated 24/25.06.2013 issued by the Department of Pension and Pensioners Welfare, which reads as follows: “4. In the case of a missing employee/pensioner/family pensioner, the family can apply for the grant of family pension, amount of salary due, leave encashment due and the amount of GPF and gratuity (whatever has not already been received) to the Head of office of the organisation where the employee/pensioner had last served, six months after lodging of police report. The family pension and/or retirement gratuity may be sanctioned by the Administrative Ministry/Department after observing the following formalities:- (i) The family must lodge a report with the concerned Police Station and obtain a report from the Police, that the employee/pensioner/family pensioner has not been traced despite efforts made by them. The report may be a First Information Report or any other report such as a Daily Diary/General Diary Entry (ii) An Indemnity Bond should be taken from the nominee/dependants of the employee/pensioner/family pensioner that all payments will be adjusted against the 4 payments due to the employee/pensioner/family pensioner in case she/he appears on the scene and makes any claim. 5. In the case of a missing employee, the family pension, at the ordinary or enhanced rate, as applicable, will accrue from the expiry of leave or the date up to which pay and allowances have been paid or the date of the police report, whichever is later. In the case of a missing pensioner/family ‘pensioner, it will accrue from the date of the police report or from the date immediately succeeding the date till which pension/family pension had been paid, whichever is later. 6. The retirement gratuity will be paid to the family within three months of the date of application. In case of any delay, the interest shall be paid at the applicable rates and responsibility for delay shall be fixed. The difference between the death gratuity and retirement gratuity shall be payable after the death of the employee is conclusively established or on the expiry of the period of seven years from the date of the police report.” In similar circumstances, Delhi High Court in W.P.(C) No.1577 of 2016 had granted full pension to the eligible family members of the deceased employee. Relying on the aforesaid proposition of law and applying it to the factual matrix of the case, the Tribunal had granted necessary relief to the respondent widow. We do not find any reason to interfere with the well reasoned order passed by the Tribunal.

whether family members of misssing employee can claim family pension etc., ?

her husband, who was missing for last seven years, may be deemed not to be alive, the respondent approached the petitioners for grant of terminal benefits, pension/family pension etc.= the scope of grant of retiral benefits to family members of a missing employee as provided in OM No.F.No.1/17/2011-P&PW(E), dated 24/25.06.2013 issued by the Department of Pension and Pensioners Welfare, which reads as follows: “4. In the case of a missing employee/pensioner/family pensioner, the family can apply for the grant of family pension, amount of salary due, leave encashment due and the amount of GPF and gratuity (whatever has not already been received) to the Head of office of the organisation where the employee/pensioner had last served, six months after lodging of police report. The family pension and/or retirement gratuity may be sanctioned by the Administrative Ministry/Department after observing the following formalities:- (i) The family must lodge a report with the concerned Police Station and obtain a report from the Police, that the employee/pensioner/family pensioner has not been traced despite efforts made by them. The report may be a First Information Report or any other report such as a Daily Diary/General Diary Entry (ii) An Indemnity Bond should be taken from the nominee/dependants of the employee/pensioner/family pensioner that all payments will be adjusted against the 4 payments due to the employee/pensioner/family pensioner in case she/he appears on the scene and makes any claim. 5. In the case of a missing employee, the family pension, at the ordinary or enhanced rate, as applicable, will accrue from the expiry of leave or the date up to which pay and allowances have been paid or the date of the police report, whichever is later. In the case of a missing pensioner/family ‘pensioner, it will accrue from the date of the police report or from the date immediately succeeding the date till which pension/family pension had been paid, whichever is later. 6. The retirement gratuity will be paid to the family within three months of the date of application. In case of any delay, the interest shall be paid at the applicable rates and responsibility for delay shall be fixed. The difference between the death gratuity and retirement gratuity shall be payable after the death of the employee is conclusively established or on the expiry of the period of seven years from the date of the police report.” In similar circumstances, Delhi High Court in W.P.(C) No.1577 of 2016 had granted full pension to the eligible family members of the deceased employee. Relying on the aforesaid proposition of law and applying it to the factual matrix of the case, the Tribunal had granted necessary relief to the respondent widow. We do not find any reason to interfere with the well reasoned order passed by the Tribunal.

AP HIGH COURT

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE JOYMALYA BAGCHI

AND

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE A.V.SESHA SAI

WRIT PETITION No.4332 of 2021

1.The Senior Superintendent of Post Offices and others

-VERSES-

Smt.M.Kumari

(Taken up through video conferencing)

ORDER: (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice Joymalya Bagchi)

Order dated 09.01.2020 in O.A.No.20/757/2019 passed by

the Central Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, (for short,

‘the Tribunal’) directing the petitioners to grant pension to the

respondent from 06.10.2000 to 05.10.2007 and other retrial

benefits and thereafter, family pension to her as per Rules by

reckoning the date of missing as 06.10.2000 is the subject matter

of challenge.

The husband of the respondent was working as Postal

Assistant. He went missing on and from 06.10.2000. The

respondent sent a complaint to the police station on 14.05.2015 by

registered post, but no steps were taken. Accordingly, she

approached Judicial First Class Magistrate, Parchur with a prayer

for initiation of investigation under Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C.

Pursuant to the order passed by the Magistrate, the police

undertook investigation and submitted a report whereupon the

learned Magistrate by order dated 14.11.2017 recorded as follows:

“The Defacto Complainant/ Madugula Kumari, w/o. Ravi

Kumar has filed a report in this Court and the same was

forwarded to the S.H.O. Inkollu PS for investigation and report

about missing of Ravi Kumar. Police have conducted investigation

and filed a refer report as “Action Dropped” as the missing man is

not traced. As per Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872,

the burden of proving that a person, who is unheard for 7 years

by his close relatives and friends is alive, is on the person who

asserts that he is alive. Nobody is asserting that Madugula Ravi 

 2

Kumar is alive. He is unheard from October 2000. So, this Court

is bound to presume that missing man is no more. Hence, the

refer charge sheet filed by Police can be accepted.”

In view of the aforesaid finding of the Magistrate that her

husband, who was missing for last seven years, may be deemed

not to be alive, the respondent approached the petitioners for grant

of terminal benefits, pension/family pension etc. Petitioners

denied such relief, hence the respondent was constrained to

approach the Tribunal. The Tribunal after hearing the parties and

referring to OM No.F.No.1/17/2011-P&PW(E), dated

24/25.06.2013 of the Department of Pension and Pensioners

Welfare passed the aforesaid direction.

Learned Assistant Solicitor General argues that there is no

clear finding that the respondent’s husband is missing. On the

other hand, he had absconded from duty and proceedings had

been initiated against him. Hence, the order requires to be set

aside.

We have given anxious consideration to such submission in

the light of the facts on record. Admittedly, the husband of the

respondent was missing on and from 06.10.2000. Proceedings

were initiated ex parte and his services were unilaterally

terminated on 29.07.2005 without service of charge memo upon

the employee.

It is apposite to note that the so-called order of termination

was void abinitio as no notice including charge memo had been

served upon the employee in the manner as contemplated under

the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules

(for short, ‘CCS (CCA) Rules’). No effort had been made to publish 

 3

notice in respect of the charge memo in accordance with CCS

(CCA) Rules, particularly, Chapter 12 thereof requiring publication

of charge memo or gist thereof in the local newspaper or uploading

the same in the website of the organisation or pasting it in the

notice board of the organisation.

On the other hand, police investigation showed that the

employee was missing and pursuant to such investigation, the

Judicial First Class Magistrate passed order on 14.11.2017 that

the missing person, who was unheard for the last seven years, may

be deemed to have died. The aforesaid factual matrix clearly falls

within the scope of grant of retiral benefits to family members of a

missing employee as provided in OM No.F.No.1/17/2011-P&PW(E),

dated 24/25.06.2013 issued by the Department of Pension and

Pensioners Welfare, which reads as follows:

“4. In the case of a missing employee/pensioner/family

pensioner, the family can apply for the grant of family pension,

amount of salary due, leave encashment due and the amount of

GPF and gratuity (whatever has not already been received) to the

Head of office of the organisation where the employee/pensioner

had last served, six months after lodging of police report. The

family pension and/or retirement gratuity may be sanctioned by the

Administrative Ministry/Department after observing the following

formalities:-

(i) The family must lodge a report with the concerned Police

Station and obtain a report from the Police, that the

employee/pensioner/family pensioner has not been traced

despite efforts made by them. The report may be a First

Information Report or any other report such as a Daily

Diary/General Diary Entry

(ii) An Indemnity Bond should be taken from the

nominee/dependants of the employee/pensioner/family

pensioner that all payments will be adjusted against the 

 4

payments due to the employee/pensioner/family pensioner

in case she/he appears on the scene and makes any claim.

5. In the case of a missing employee, the family pension, at

the ordinary or enhanced rate, as applicable, will accrue from the

expiry of leave or the date up to which pay and allowances have

been paid or the date of the police report, whichever is later. In the

case of a missing pensioner/family ‘pensioner, it will accrue from

the date of the police report or from the date immediately

succeeding the date till which pension/family pension had been

paid, whichever is later.

6. The retirement gratuity will be paid to the family within

three months of the date of application. In case of any delay, the

interest shall be paid at the applicable rates and responsibility for

delay shall be fixed. The difference between the death gratuity and

retirement gratuity shall be payable after the death of the employee

is conclusively established or on the expiry of the period of seven

years from the date of the police report.”

In similar circumstances, Delhi High Court in

W.P.(C) No.1577 of 2016 had granted full pension to the eligible

family members of the deceased employee. Relying on the

aforesaid proposition of law and applying it to the factual matrix of

the case, the Tribunal had granted necessary relief to the

respondent widow. We do not find any reason to interfere with the

well reasoned order passed by the Tribunal.

The Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. No order as to

costs. As a sequel, Miscellaneous Petitions, if any, pending in the

Writ Petition shall stand closed.

______________________________

JUSTICE JOYMALYA BAGCHI

__________________________

JUSTICE A.V.SESHA SAI

Date: 23.02.2021

Ivd 

as per the provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003, the Government of Andhra Pradesh/APERC notified minimum compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- to the bereaved family in case of nondepartmental fatal electrical accidents vide the Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission Compensation to Victims of Electrical Accidents Regulation, 2017 (Regulation No.2 of 2017). Therefore, the respondents are under an obligation to pay the compensation amount of Rs.5,00,000/- to the petitioner for loss of her husband as a result of electrocution. Learned counsel would also submit that the erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh and the common High Court, in similar set of facts and circumstances, directed the electricity authorities to consider the case of the parties for payment of compensation.

 Ambati Eswar Reddy, while trying to switch on starter of motor pump set to irrigate the agricultural field, met with fatal electrical accident due to high voltage and electrical short circuit and died instantaneously. The said accident is a non-departmental fatal accident. Police also registered a case in Crime No.111 of 2019, and conducted inquest. The autopsy conducted by the Civil Assistant Surgeon, District Headquarters Hospital, Nandyal, revealed that the cause of death is ‘electrical shock’. The petitioner’s family is eking out livelihood by doing agriculture. The petitioner approached the concerned authorities several times for payment of ex-gratia/compensation, but in vain. Therefore, the 2 MGR,J WP_4310_2021 petitioner submitted representation, dated 21.12.2020 to the respondents. Inspite of receipt of the said notice, no action is taken by the respondents. Hence, assailing the inaction of the respondents to pay the compensation, this writ petition is filed.

as per the provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003, the Government of Andhra Pradesh/APERC notified minimum compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- to the bereaved family in case of nondepartmental fatal electrical accidents vide the Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission Compensation to Victims of Electrical Accidents Regulation, 2017 (Regulation No.2 of 2017). Therefore, the respondents are under an obligation to pay the compensation amount of Rs.5,00,000/- to the petitioner for loss of her husband as a result of electrocution. Learned counsel would also submit that the erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh and the common High Court, in similar set of facts and circumstances, directed the electricity authorities to consider the case of the parties for payment of compensation.


AP HIGH COURT

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE M. GANGA RAO

Writ Petition No.4310 of 2021

AMBATI SAVITHRI

-VERSES-

SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED

ORDER

 This writ petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, is filed

seeking the following relief/s:

“…to issue a Writ in the nature of Writ of Mandamus or an appropriate

writ or order or direction to the respondents herein, holding that the

inaction on the part of the respondents for not paying minimum

compensation of Rs.5.00 Lakhs (Rupees five Lakhs only) to the petitioner

herein, for the death of her husband Ambati Eswar Reddy, due to

“Electric Shock” on 15.08.2019 as per A.P Gazette notification No.241,

Date 29.05.2017, and in terms of the principle of law laid down by the

Hon’ble High Court of Judicature, Hyderabad, in a similar case, in its

orders dated 24.12.2012 in W.P.No.35215 of 2012, even after lapse of

considerable time as illegal, arbitrary and violation of fundamental rights

guaranteed under the Constitution and consequently to direct the

respondents to pay exgratia of Rs.5.00 lakhs to the petitioner herein,

within a time bound period and pass such other order or orders…”

 Heard Sri Hari Kishan Kudikala, learned counsel for the petitioner, and

Sri Y. Nagi Reddy, learned standing counsel appearing for the respondents.

Perused the material on record.

 The case of the petitioner is that, on 15.08.2019, her husband Ambati

Eswar Reddy, while trying to switch on starter of motor pump set to irrigate

the agricultural field, met with fatal electrical accident due to high voltage

and electrical short circuit and died instantaneously. The said accident is a

non-departmental fatal accident. Police also registered a case in Crime No.111

of 2019, and conducted inquest. The autopsy conducted by the Civil Assistant

Surgeon, District Headquarters Hospital, Nandyal, revealed that the cause of

death is ‘electrical shock’. The petitioner’s family is eking out livelihood by

doing agriculture. The petitioner approached the concerned authorities several

times for payment of ex-gratia/compensation, but in vain. Therefore, the 

2

MGR,J

WP_4310_2021

petitioner submitted representation, dated 21.12.2020 to the respondents.

Inspite of receipt of the said notice, no action is taken by the respondents.

Hence, assailing the inaction of the respondents to pay the compensation, this

writ petition is filed.

 Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as per the provisions of

the Electricity Act, 2003, the Government of Andhra Pradesh/APERC notified

minimum compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- to the bereaved family in case of nondepartmental fatal electrical accidents vide the Andhra Pradesh Electricity

Regulatory Commission Compensation to Victims of Electrical Accidents

Regulation, 2017 (Regulation No.2 of 2017). Therefore, the respondents are

under an obligation to pay the compensation amount of Rs.5,00,000/- to the

petitioner for loss of her husband as a result of electrocution. Learned counsel

would also submit that the erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh and the

common High Court, in similar set of facts and circumstances, directed the

electricity authorities to consider the case of the parties for payment of

compensation. Non consideration of the representation, by way of legal

notice, of the petitioner for payment of ex-gratia/compensation as per the

Regulations and earlier orders of the High Court is illegal and arbitrary.

 Learned sanding counsel submits that for quantifying the compensation,

the petitioner has to approach the civil Court.

 The said contention is untenable. For payment of ex-gratia and other

benefits under the schemes, public law remedy is available before this Court.

 Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, submissions of

both the counsel and on perusal of the material record, this Court, in the

interests of justice, felt it appropriate to dispose of the writ petition directing

the respondents to consider the representation submitted by the petitioner, in

terms of Regulation No.2 of 2017 of the Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory 

3

MGR,J

WP_4310_2021

Commission, for payment of ex-gratia within a period of six weeks from the

date of receipt of a copy of this order.

 With the above directions, the Writ Petition is disposed of. There shall

be no order as to costs.

As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand

closed.

______________

M.GANGA RAO, J

23.02.2021

Vjl 

4

MGR,J

WP_4310_2021

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE M. GANGA RAO

Writ Petition No.4310 of 2021

23.02.2021

Vjl 

whether the legal heir of a contract employee, who sustained grave injury in the accident while in service, is entitled to claim compassionate appointment ? This issue is squarely covered by the order dated 02.01.2018 in the case of T. Suseela vs. The State represented by the Secretary to Government, Rural Development Department, Secretariat, Chennai-9 [W.P(MD)No.10238 of 2020 and MP(MD)Nos.1 & 2 of 2010] passed by the Single Judge of Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, wherein the Single Judge after considering various judgments of Supreme Court decided the issue against the petitioner therein. However, the request of this petitioner is limited i.e., to consider the representation dated 24.07.2017. Hence, the 4th respondent is requested to dispose of the representation dated 24.07.2017 submitted by the petitioner to the District Collector, Guntur keeping in view the law laid down by the Single Judge of Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in T. Suseela’s case (referred supra) and the law declared therein, within a period of four (04) weeks, from the date of receipt of a copy of this order

whether the legal heir of a contract employee, who sustained grave injury in the accident while in service, is entitled to claim compassionate appointment ?

This issue is squarely covered by the order dated 02.01.2018 in the case of T. Suseela vs. The State represented by the Secretary to Government, Rural Development Department, Secretariat, Chennai-9 [W.P(MD)No.10238 of 2020 and MP(MD)Nos.1 & 2 of 2010] passed by the Single Judge of Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, wherein the Single Judge after considering various judgments of Supreme Court decided the issue against the petitioner therein. However, the request of this petitioner is limited i.e., to consider the representation dated 24.07.2017. Hence, the 4th respondent is requested to dispose of the representation dated 24.07.2017 submitted by the petitioner to the District Collector, Guntur keeping in view the law laid down by the Single Judge of Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in T. Suseela’s case (referred supra) and the law declared therein, within a period of four (04) weeks, from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

AP HIGH COURT

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE M.SATYANARAYANA MURTHY

WRIT PETITION NO.1394 OF 2021

R PEDABABU

-verses-

The State of Andhra Pradesh

ORDER:

 This petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of

India seeking the following relief:-

“….to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate

writ order or direction declaring the Award dated

15042014 passed in Lok Adalat Case No.23 of 2014 on the

file of Lok Adalat Bench Macherla against FIR No.92/2013

on the file of Durgi Police Station Guntur District which

was registered as C.C.No.445/2013 on the file of Junior

Civil Judge Macherla and further inaction of the

respondents in providing any employment without

assigning any reason or passing any order by following the

due process of law against representation dated 15.11.2019

as illegal arbitrary non-est in the eye of law and violative of

Articles 14 16 21 of Constitution of India principles of

natural justice and pass such other order.”

2. The main grievance of this petitioner is that his father by name

Koteswara Rao worked as lineman on contract basis under

respondents 8 and 9 in the department of respondents 2 to 7, he met

with an accident and sustained grave injury while in service as

contract employee under respondents 8 and 9, totally disabled and

he is not in a position to discharge his duties. Therefore, the

petitioner made a representation dated 15.11.2019 to the

Superintendent of Police, Guntur Rural and not to any of the

respondents. However, he made another representation allegedly to

the District Collector, Guntur on 24.07.2017 for his appointment on

compassionate ground. Non-consideration of his request to appoint

on compassionate grounds is now questioned before this Court and

requested to declare the same as illegal and arbitrary. 

2

3. During the course of hearing, Sri T.Ramakoteswara Rao,

learned counsel for the petitioner requested this Court to issue a

direction to the respondents to consider the representation of the

petitioner dated 24.07.2017 submitted to the District Collector,

Guntur, without touching the merits of the case.

4. On the other hand, Sri Y.Nagi Reddy, learned Standing

Counsel for A.P.S.P.D.C.L appearing for the respondents contended

that the representation dated 15.11.2019 was addressed to the

Superintendent of Police, Guntur Rural and not to any of the

respondents, but he marked copies to the Deputy Superintendent of

Police, Gurazala, Circle Inspector of Police, Macherla Rural and

Sub-Inspector of Police, Durgi Police Station, the same cannot be

taken into consideration. However, the representation made to the

District Collector, Guntur dated 24.07.2017 is not in dispute. But,

now the question is whether the legal heir of a contract employee,

who sustained grave injury in the accident while in service, is

entitled to claim compassionate appointment.

5. This issue is squarely covered by the order dated 02.01.2018

in the case of T. Suseela vs. The State represented by the

Secretary to Government, Rural Development Department,

Secretariat, Chennai-9 [W.P(MD)No.10238 of 2020 and

MP(MD)Nos.1 & 2 of 2010] passed by the Single Judge of Madurai

Bench of Madras High Court, wherein the Single Judge after

considering various judgments of Supreme Court decided the issue

against the petitioner therein. However, the request of this petitioner

is limited i.e., to consider the representation dated 24.07.2017. 

3

Hence, the 4th respondent is requested to dispose of the

representation dated 24.07.2017 submitted by the petitioner to the

District Collector, Guntur keeping in view the law laid down by the

Single Judge of Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in T. Suseela’s

case (referred supra) and the law declared therein, within a period of

four (04) weeks, from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

5. With the above direction, this Writ Petition is disposed of.

There shall be no order as to costs.

 Consequently miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall

also stand closed.

_________________________________________

JUSTICE M. SATYANARAYANA MURTHY

Date: 20.01.2021

IS 

4

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE M.SATYANARAYANA MURTHY

WRIT PETITION NO.1394 OF 2021

Dated 20.01.2021

IS 

permitting the petitioners to collect the rates of admission as mentioned in their respective representations to the respondents for the Telugu movie “RED” which is proposed to be released soon, subject to strictly adhering to the circular instructions issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh from time to time and Standard Operating Procedure issued by Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India dated 06.10.2020 for exhibition of films on preventive measures to contain spread of Covid-19 and subject to compliance of direction issued in earlier order passed in W.P.No.9734 of 2019 and batch, following the order of Division Bench in W.P.No.18779 of 2014.

permitting the petitioners to collect the rates of admission as mentioned in their respective representations to the respondents for the Telugu movie “RED” which is proposed to be released soon, subject to strictly adhering to the circular instructions issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh from time to time and Standard Operating Procedure issued by Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India dated 06.10.2020 for exhibition of films on preventive measures to contain spread of Covid-19 and subject to compliance of direction issued in earlier order passed in W.P.No.9734 of 2019 and batch, following the order of Division Bench in W.P.No.18779 of 2014. 

Wednesday, March 3, 2021

Section 457 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C”) for grant of interim custody of his vehicle = whether a vehicle seized in connection with crime registered under the provisions of the NDPS Act is liable for confiscation or not only at the time of convicting, acquitting or discharging the accused. But there is no mention that interim custody of a vehicle cannot be ordered. Further, if the vehicle is kept idle it will render useless and there is every likelihood of the vehicle getting damaged.

 Section 457 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C”) for grant of interim custody of his vehicle =  whether a vehicle seized in connection with crime registered under the provisions of the NDPS Act is liable for confiscation or not only at the time of convicting, acquitting or discharging the accused. But there is no mention that interim custody of a vehicle cannot be ordered. Further, if the vehicle is kept idle it will render useless and there is every likelihood of the vehicle getting damaged.

AP HIGH COURT 

THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI

CRIMINAL REVISION CASE No.150 of 2021

BATHINA ANAND MOHAN RAO
Versus
THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH

ORDER:

 Challenging the order dated 04.01.2021 in Crl.M.P.No.176 of

2020 on the file of Metropolitan Sessions Judge-cum-I Additional

District & Sessions Judge-Special Judge for Trial of Offences under

NDPS Act, Visakhapatnam in connection with Crime No.487 of

2020 of Duvvada Police Station, Visakhapatnam City, dismissing

the petition filed by the petitioner herein under Section 457 of

Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C”) for grant of

interim custody of his vehicle i.e. Maruthi Celerio ZXI Car bearing

Registration No.AP 39 AE 3378, this criminal revision case under

Section 397 & 401 of Cr.P.C. has been filed.

2. Heard Sri T.D.Phani Kumar, learned counsel for the

petitioner and the learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing

on behalf of the 1st respondent-State.

3. Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the

Court below dismissed the application filed under Section 457 of

Cr.P.C on the ground that the vehicle is likely to be confiscated to

the State, if ultimately the case results in conviction. It has further

observed that the vehicle was used for transportation of Ganja and

as the investigation is still pending, the petitioner is not entitled for

interim custody of the vehicle during the pendency of the case.

Learned counsel submits that the Court below has failed to

exercise its jurisdiction under Section 457 of Cr.P.C and moreover,

there is no dispute about the ownership of the vehicle and that the

petitioner is not involved in the crime. Learned counsel submits 

2

that just because the investigation is pending, that cannot be a

ground to refuse the petition filed under Section 457 of Cr.P.C.

4. Learned counsel for the petitioner also submits that even if a

vehicle is seized under NDPS Act for being used in transporting

narcotic goods, the owner is entitled for interim custody of the

vehicle and this Court has granted interim custody of the vehicles

in similar cases. Hence, this petition may be allowed.

5. It is appropriate to extract Section 457 of Cr.P.C which reads

thus:

457. Procedure by police upon seizure of property.

 (1) Whenever the seizure of property by any police officer

is reported to a Magistrate under the provisions of this Code,

and such property is not produced before a Criminal Court

during an inquiry or trial, the Magistrate may make such order

as he thinks fit respecting the disposal of such property or the

delivery of such property to the person entitled to the

possession thereof, or if such person cannot be ascertained,

respecting the custody and production of such property.

(2) If the person so entitled is known, the Magistrate

may order the property to be delivered to him on such

conditions (if any) as the Magistrate thinks fit and if such

person is unknown, the Magistrate may detain it and shall, in

such case, issue a proclamation specifying the articles of which

such property consists, and requiring any person who may

have a claim thereto, to appear before him and establish his

claim within six months from the date of such proclamation.

6. As per Section 457 of Cr.P.C., if the person is known and

when there is no dispute about the ownership of the vehicle, the

Magistrate may order property be delivered to him on such

conditions as the Magistrate thinks fit.

7. In this case, there is no dispute with regard to the ownership

of the petitioner in respect of the seized vehicle. It is clear that 

3

there is no bar under the NDPS Act on the Courts to order for

interim custody of a vehicle which is seized in a crime registered

under the provisions of NDPS Act. Section 63 of the NDPS Act

reads thus:

“(1) In the trial of offences under this Act, whether the accused

is convicted or acquitted or discharged, the court shall decide

whether any article or thing seized under this Act is liable to

confiscation under section 60 or section 61 or section 62 and,

if it decides that the article is so liable, it may order

confiscation accordingly.

(2) Where any article or thing seized under this Act appears to

be liable to confiscation under section 60 or section 61 or

section 62, but the person who committed the offence in

connection therewith is not known or cannot be found, the

court may inquire into and decide such liability, and may order

confiscation accordingly: Provided that no order of confiscation

of an article or thing shall be made until the expiry of one

month from the date of seizure, or without hearing any person

who may claim any right thereto and the evidence, if any,

which he produces in respect of his claim: Provided further

that if any such article or thing, other than a narcotic drug,

psychotropic substance, 1[controlled substance,] the opium

poppy, coca plant or cannabis plant is liable to speedy and

natural decay, or if the court is of opinion that its sale would

be for the benefit of its owner, it may at any time direct it to be

sold; and the provisions of this sub-section shall, as nearly as

may be practicable, apply to the net proceeds of the sale.

8. From the above, it is clear that the Court shall decide

whether a vehicle seized in connection with crime registered under

the provisions of the NDPS Act is liable for confiscation or not only

at the time of convicting, acquitting or discharging the accused.

But there is no mention that interim custody of a vehicle cannot be

ordered. Further, if the vehicle is kept idle it will render useless

and there is every likelihood of the vehicle getting damaged.

9. Taking into consideration the submissions made by the

learned counsel for the petitioner and in view of settled law, this 

4

Court feels it appropriate to grant interim custody of the vehicle to

the petitioner by imposing certain conditions.

10. Accordingly, the criminal revision case is allowed and the

order dated 04.01.2021 in Crl.M.P.No.176 of 2020 on the file of

Metropolitan Sessions Judge-cum-I Additional District & Sessions

Judge-Special Judge for Trial of Offences under NDPS Act,

Visakhapatnam is set aside. The vehicle i.e. Maruthi Celerio ZXI

Car bearing Registration No.AP 39 AE 3378 is ordered to be given

interim custody to the petitioner on condition of his executing a

self bond for a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- (Rupees three lakhs only)

with one surety for a likesum to the satisfaction of learned

Metropolitan Sessions Judge-cum-I Additional District & Sessions

Judge-Special Judge for Trial of Offences under NDPS Act,

Visakhapatnam.

As a sequel, all the pending miscellaneous applications are

closed.

___________________________

LALITHA KANNEGANTI, J

26th February, 2021

PVD 

5

THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI

Allowed

CRIMINAL REVISION CASE No.150 of 2021

26th February, 2021

PVD 

Monday, March 1, 2021

Jurisdiction - family court - The revision petitioner filed the above F.C.O.P under Section 11 r/w. Section 5(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act,1955 against his wife and another, seeking to nullify the marriage. The said F.C.O.P was returned with an objection about the maintainability of F.C.O.P on the ground of territorial jurisdiction. The petitioner in his petition affidavit clearly stated that he along with his wife has resided lastly at Guntur in a house bearing D.No.16-18-4, Burlevari Street, Old Guntur. In support of his contention, he also filed Aaadhar Card evidencing proof his address. Inspite of the said fact, the learned trial judge returned the F.C.O.P with an endorsement to file it before the appropriate court having territorial jurisdiction. Assailing the said order, the present Civil Revision Petition is filed. =. As per the Aadhar Card, filed by the revision petitioner, it clearly shows that the revision petitioner is residing in a house bearing D.No.16-18-4, Burlevari Street, Old Guntur. As per the averments in the petition affidavit of unnumbered F.C.O.P of 2020, the petitioner along with his wife has resided lastly in the 2 said house. As such, in the considered opinion of this court, the court below is having territorial jurisdiction to hear the matter.

Jurisdiction - family court - The revision petitioner filed the above F.C.O.P under Section 11 r/w. Section 5(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act,1955 against his wife and another, seeking to nullify the marriage. The said F.C.O.P was returned with an objection about the maintainability of F.C.O.P on the ground of territorial jurisdiction. The petitioner in his petition affidavit clearly stated that he along with his wife has resided lastly at Guntur in a house bearing D.No.16-18-4, Burlevari Street, Old Guntur. In support of his contention, he also filed Aaadhar Card evidencing proof his address. Inspite of the said fact, the learned trial judge returned the F.C.O.P with an endorsement to file it before the appropriate court having territorial jurisdiction. Assailing the said order, the present Civil Revision Petition is filed. =. As per the Aadhar Card, filed by the revision petitioner, it clearly shows that the revision petitioner is residing in a house bearing D.No.16-18-4, Burlevari Street, Old Guntur. As per the averments in the petition affidavit of unnumbered F.C.O.P of 2020, the petitioner along with his wife has resided lastly in the 2 said house. As such, in the considered opinion of this court, the court below is having territorial jurisdiction to hear the matter.

AP HIGH COURT 

HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY

C.R.P.NO.73 OF 2021

Meduri Kalyan,
Versus
Meduri Rama Devi,

ORDER:-

The Civil Revision Petition is filed being aggrieved by the

docket order, dated 01-02-2020 passed in C.F.R.No.84 of 2020

in unnumbered F.C.O.P.No. of 2020 by the XII Additional

District and Sessions Judge-cum-Family Judge, Guntur.

The revision petitioner filed the above F.C.O.P under

Section 11 r/w. Section 5(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act,1955

against his wife and another, seeking to nullify the marriage. The

said F.C.O.P was returned with an objection about the

maintainability of F.C.O.P on the ground of territorial jurisdiction.

The petitioner in his petition affidavit clearly stated that he along

with his wife has resided lastly at Guntur in a house bearing

D.No.16-18-4, Burlevari Street, Old Guntur. In support of his

contention, he also filed Aaadhar Card evidencing proof his

address. Inspite of the said fact, the learned trial judge returned

the F.C.O.P with an endorsement to file it before the appropriate

court having territorial jurisdiction. Assailing the said order, the

present Civil Revision Petition is filed.

Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner.

This Court has gone through the entire material papers on

record and perused the order, which is impugned in this revision

petition. As per the Aadhar Card, filed by the revision petitioner,

it clearly shows that the revision petitioner is residing in a house

bearing D.No.16-18-4, Burlevari Street, Old Guntur. As per the

averments in the petition affidavit of unnumbered F.C.O.P of

2020, the petitioner along with his wife has resided lastly in the 

 2

said house. As such, in the considered opinion of this court, the

court below is having territorial jurisdiction to hear the matter.

In that view of the matter, the docket order passed by the court

below is not sustainable and the same is liable to be set aside.

Accordingly, the docket order, dated 01-02-2020, passed

in C.F.R.No.84 of 2020 in unnumbered F.C.O.P.No. of 2020 by

the XII Additional District and Sessions Judge-cum-Family Judge,

Guntur is set aside and the learned XII Additional District and

Sessions Judge-cum-Family Judge, Guntur is directed to register

the F.C.O.P on its file and proceed with the case in accordance

with law.

With the above observation, the Civil Revision Petition is

disposed of at the stage of admission. No order as to costs.

Miscellaneous Petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed

in consequence.

__________________

K.SURESH REDDY,J

29th JANUARY, 2021

TSNR 

Wednesday, February 10, 2021

No plaint be returned several times on same objections without placing the same before the officer for hearing =As stated supra, the suit was filed by the petitioners herein, the plaint was returned on 06.07.2020 with certain objections, the same was represented complying with the said objections on 08.07.2020, again returned on 13.07.2020 raising similar objections adding some more objections and they were complied with and represented on 15.07.2020, again returned on 17.07.2020 with five (5) objections which were complied with and represented on 21.07.2020, finally returned on 22.07.2020 with nine (9) objections by the Office/Registry of the trial Court. In all these occasions, at the time of representation the petitioners sought for placing the matter before the trial Court for hearing on the office objections and the compliance reported with the explanation of the plaintiffs. But, the Office/Registry of the Court below miserably failed in it’s duty by not placing the matter before the Court below for hearing at the first instance itself soon after compliance of the objections dated 06.07.2020 by the petitioners/plaintiffs vide representation dated 08.07.2020 itself. The action of the Office/Registry of the trial Court in not placing the matter before the Court below so far for hearing on objections, compliance and representation of the plaint is in gross violation of Rule 22 and Rule 23 of the Civil Rules of Practice and Circular Orders, 1990.

No plaint be returned several times on same objections without placing the same before the officer for hearing =As stated supra, the suit was filed by the petitioners herein, the plaint was returned on 06.07.2020 with certain objections, the same was represented complying with the said objections on 08.07.2020, again returned on 13.07.2020 raising similar objections adding some more objections and they were complied with and represented on 15.07.2020, again returned on 17.07.2020 with five (5) objections which were complied with and represented on 21.07.2020, finally returned on 22.07.2020 with nine (9) objections by the Office/Registry of the trial Court. In all these occasions, at the time of representation the petitioners sought for placing the matter before the trial Court for hearing on the office objections and the compliance reported with the explanation of the plaintiffs. But, the Office/Registry of the Court below miserably failed in it’s duty by not placing the matter before the Court below for hearing at the first instance itself soon after compliance of the objections dated 06.07.2020 by the petitioners/plaintiffs vide representation dated 08.07.2020 itself. The action of the Office/Registry of the trial Court in not placing the matter before the Court below so far for hearing on objections, compliance and representation of the plaint is in gross violation of Rule 22 and Rule 23  of the Civil Rules of Practice and Circular Orders, 1990.

AP HIGH COURT 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI

****

CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.960 OF 2020

Between:

Manthina Sitarama Raju & 2 others

 --- Petitioners


And

Kanda Rambabu & 2 others

--- Respondents



DATE OF ORDER PRONOUNCED : 04.09.2020

SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B. KRISHNA MOHAN

1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers

may be allowed to see the order? Yes/No

2. Whether the copy of order may be

marked to Law Reporters/Journals? Yes

3. Whether His Lordship wish to

see the fair copy of the order? Yes/No

_______________________

 JUSTICE B. KRISHNA MOHAN. 

 2 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

* THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B. KRISHNA MOHAN

+ CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.960 OF 2020


% 04.09.2020

# Between:

Manthina Sitarama Raju & 2 others

 --- Petitioners


And

Kanda Rambabu & 2 others

--- Respondents


! Counsel for the Petitioners : Sri Pappu Srinivasa Rao

^ Counsel for the Respondents : --

< Gist:

> Head Note:

? Cases referred:


This court made the following : 

 3 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE B.KRISHNA MOHAN

CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.960 OF 2020

ORDER :

This Civil Revision Petition is filed against the O.S.S.R.No.1228 of

2020 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Peddapuram with return

objections on the plaint, dated 22.07.2020.

2. Heard the counsel for the petitioners.

3. The petitioners are the plaintiffs in the suit in O.S.S.R.No.1228 of

2020 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Peddapuram. The

respondents are the defendants in the said suit. The suit is filed for

grant of permanent injunction restraining the 3rd defendant and her

henchmen from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment

of the plaintiffs and the defendants No.1 and 2 over the plaint A, B, C

schedule properties including B, B1, D, D1 red marked portion shown in

the plaint plan and grant of such other reliefs, in the interest of justice.

The suit was initially filed on 03.07.2020 and it was numbered as

O.S.S.R.No.1228 of 2020, dated 06.07.2020. The plaint was returned

with certain office objections, dated 06.07.2020, as follows :

1. As per document No.1 partition deed dated

02.11.2002 the surname of Plaintiffs is

“Srimanthina”. The signatures of plaintiffs with

their surnames is not tallied in the plaint as per

partition deed, likewise vakalat etc. 

 4 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

2. The plaint plan is not tallied with the contents of

plaint as well as plaint schedules.

3. How the plaintiffs 2 and 3 are entitled to file this

suit, as Defendants 1 and 2 are present owners of

plaint “A” and “B” schedule properties – should be

explained.

Hence, returned, time 7 days.

Complying the said objections with an explanation, it was

represented on 08.07.2020 with a further request if not satisfied with

the compliance; the same may be put up before the Hon’ble Court for

hearing on the objections and compliance.

But, the Office/Registry of the trial Court again returned the

plaint on 13.07.2020 elaborating the very same earlier objections into

serial Nos.1 to 17 giving seven (7) days time for compliance by the

plaintiffs. Then all the objections were complied again and represented

on 15.07.2020 with the same request if not satisfied the same may be

put up before the Hon’ble Court for it’s hearing on the objections and

compliance. Even this time also the Office/the Registry again returned

the plaint on 17.07.2020 with the objections in serial Nos.1 to 5

requiring the plaintiffs to comply within seven (7) days. This time also

the plaintiffs have represented the plaint complying the objections with

necessary explanation on 21.07.2020. The earlier request of placing the

matter before the Court for hearing if not satisfied with the compliance

on objections is reiterated. Ignoring the compliance and request of

placing the matter before the Court below for hearing, the Office/the

Registry of the trial Court again returned the plaint in O.S.S.R.No.1228 

 5 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

of 2020, on 22.07.2020 raising similar objections in serial Nos.1 to 9

giving seven (7) days time for compliance. Aggrieved by the same, the

plaintiffs/petitioners filed this Revision before this Court under Article

227 of the Constitution of India.

4. It is to be noted that since it is at the stage of numbering of the

suit only, the trial Court did not order any notices to the defendants

and the trial Court has not even heard on return of plaint by the

Office/Registry with certain objections. Hence, this Court also

proceeds with the hearing of this Revision without ordering any notice

to the respondents. In the similar lines this Court already disposed of

C.R.P.No.3019 of 2018, dated 08.06.2018, C.R.P.No.6317 of 2016, dated

22.06.2017 and C.R.P. No.5856 of 2017, dated 19.01.2018 hearing the

petitioners therein respectively at the admission stage without ordering

notices to the respondents therein respectively. Accordingly, the

counsel for the petitioners is also heard on merits, as follows :

 The learned counsel for the petitioners contended that while

registering the suit, the Court can go through the averments made in

the plaint only without going into the merits and demerits of the case,

the repeated objections taken by the Court below are beyond the

purview and scope of the provisions under Section 9 and Order VII Rule 1

of Code of Civil Procedure, whether the plaint disclosed the cause of

action or not, the trial Court is not required to examine whether the

plaintiff has got cause of action to file the suit and the Office/Registry

of the trial Court erroneously raised several objections with regard to 

 6 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

the identity of the plaint schedule property. The Office/Registry of the

Court below ought to have numbered the suit immediately when

objections dated 06.07.2020 are complied therewith instead of

repeatedly returning the plaint with certain objections and the

Office/Registry of the Court below ought to have raised all the

objections at a time and it is not expected to raise either similar type

of objections or new objections as and when the objections are

complied with at every time. Therefore, the learned counsel for the

petitioners prayed for placing the matter before the Court below for

hearing on the objections raised and compliance made with necessary

explanation.

5. In furtherance of the submissions and contentions, he relied upon

the decision of the High Court of Telangana reported in “Syed Hadi Ali

Moosavi Vs. Syeda Taquia Moosavi and Others,” 1

 the decision of

erstwhile High Court of A.P., reported in “K. Raghavendra Raju Vs. Syed

Yousuf and Others”2

, and the decision of the High Court of Judicature

at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra

Pradesh reported in “Kavitha Balaji and others Vs. State of Telangana

and Others”3

.

6. The decision reported in 2019 (4) ALT 321 pertains to rejection of

the plaint by the Court below therein upon hearing the objections on

the bench. The other decision reported in 2005 (2) ALT 645 pertains to

return of plaint by the Court below therein after hearing on the


1

 2019(4)ALT321

2

 2005(2)ALT645

3

 2017(2)ALT781

 7 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

objections. The another decision reported in 2017 (2) ALT 781 pertains

to the rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 (a) and (f) of Code

of Civil Procedure. Hence, these decisions have no application to

dispose of the present Revision as the Court below herein has not yet

heard on the objections and compliance of the plaintiffs/petitioners

herein.

7. As stated supra, the suit was filed by the petitioners herein, the

plaint was returned on 06.07.2020 with certain objections, the same

was represented complying with the said objections on 08.07.2020,

again returned on 13.07.2020 raising similar objections adding some

more objections and they were complied with and represented on

15.07.2020, again returned on 17.07.2020 with five (5) objections which

were complied with and represented on 21.07.2020, finally returned on

22.07.2020 with nine (9) objections by the Office/Registry of the trial

Court. In all these occasions, at the time of representation the

petitioners sought for placing the matter before the trial Court for

hearing on the office objections and the compliance reported with the

explanation of the plaintiffs. But, the Office/Registry of the Court

below miserably failed in it’s duty by not placing the matter before the

Court below for hearing at the first instance itself soon after

compliance of the objections dated 06.07.2020 by the

petitioners/plaintiffs vide representation dated 08.07.2020 itself. The

action of the Office/Registry of the trial Court in not placing the matter

before the Court below so far for hearing on objections, compliance and

representation of the plaint is in gross violation of Rule 22 and Rule 23 

 8 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

of the Civil Rules of Practice and Circular Orders, 1990 which reads as

follows :

22. (New) Procedure on presentation:-

a. On presentation of every plaint the same shall be entered in

Register No. 17 in Appendix II, Part-II, Volume II and examined

by the Chief Ministerial Officer of the Court.

b. If he finds that the plaint complies with all the requirements,

he shall make an endorsement on the plaint ‘Examined and

may be registered’ with the date and his signature and placed

before the Judge, The Chief Ministerial Officer shall also

endorse on the plaint or proceedings if any caveat has been

filed. If he thinks that the plaint shall be returned for

presentation to the proper court or be rejected under Order VII

Rule 11 or for any other person, he shall place the matter

before the Judge for orders.

c. Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (2) any non-compliance

with these rules or any clerical mistake may be required by the

Chief Ministerial officer to be rectified. Any rectification so

effected, shall be initialed and, dated by the party or his

advocate making the same and the Chief Ministerial Officer

shall note the number of corrections in the margin and shall

initial and date the same.

In the event of such rectification not being made within the time

specified, the Chief Ministerial Officer shall place the matter

before the Judge for Orders.

23. (New) Registration of plaint:-

Where, upon examination, the plaint is found to be in order, it

shall be entered in the register of suits, and the Judge shall pass

orders as to the issue of summons or otherwise. 

 9 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

8. The practice adopted by the Office/Registry of the trial Court in

repeatedly returning the plaint on one objection or the other touching

upon the merits and demerits of the case without placing the matter

before the Court below for hearing is deprecated, unwarranted and

contrary to Rule 22 of the Civil Rules of Practice and Circular Orders,

1990.

9. In the result, the Office/Registry of the trial Court is directed to

place the O.S.S.R.No.1228 of 2020 before the Court below for hearing

on the objections dated 22.07.2020, compliance and explanation of the

petitioners/plaintiffs with regard to all such objections within 7 days

from the date of receipt of a copy of this Order and the trial Court shall

pass appropriate orders within two (2) weeks thereafter on the receipt

of the plaint and numbering of the suit in O.S.S.R.No.1228 of 2020

keeping in view the provisions of Section 9 CPC and Order VII Rule 1

CPC.

10. Accordingly, this Civil Revision Petition is disposed of. There shall

be no order as to costs.

 As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any pending in this case,

shall stand closed.

________________________

JUSTICE B. KRISHNA MOHAN

DT. 04-09-2020

Yvk 

 10 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE B.KRISHNA MOHAN

CIVIL REVISION PETITION No. 960 OF 2020 OF 2005

 Dt. 04-09-2020

Yvk 

 11 BKM,J

 CRP No.960 of 2020 

Service of notice on corporation = Rule 2 Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908 "Service on corporation" Subject to any statutory provision regulating service of process, where the suit is against a corporation, the summons may be served. 2 (a) on the secretary, or on any director, or other principal officer of the corporation, (or) (b) by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the corporation at the registered office, or if there is no registered office then at the place where the corporation carries on business. 4. The dispute is only with regard to service of notice on the respondent, but the order impugned in the Civil Revision Petition is contrary to Rule 2 (b) Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, service by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the corporation at the registered office, or if there is no registered office then at the place where the corporation carries on business is self sufficient service, is permitted by law.

Service of notice on corporation = Rule 2 Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908 "Service on corporation" Subject to any statutory provision regulating service of process, where the suit is against a corporation, the summons may be served. 2 (a) on the secretary, or on any director, or other principal officer of the corporation, (or) (b) by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the corporation at the registered office, or if there is no registered office then at the place where the corporation carries on business. 4. The dispute is only with regard to service of notice on the respondent, but the order impugned in the Civil Revision Petition is contrary to Rule 2 (b) Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, service by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the corporation at the registered office, or if there is no registered office then at the place where the corporation carries on business is self sufficient service, is permitted by law. 

AP HIGH COURT

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE M.SATYANARAYANA MURTHY

&

THE HON’BLE SMT JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI

CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.969 OF 2020

GE Power India Limited
Versus
Navayuga Engineering Company Limited,

ORDER: (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice M.Satyanarayana Murthy)

This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is

filed questioning the order dated 27.07.2020 in

C.A.O.P.No.2 of 2020 passed by the Special Judge for trial of

Commercial Disputes, Ibrahimpatnam, Vijayawada.

2. The Special Judge for trial of Commercial Disputes,

Ibrahimpatnam, Vijayawada ordered notice to the respondent and

accordingly the petitioner appears to have sent the notice to the

respondent, but the trial Court by the order impugned in the Civil

Revision Petition held that ‘the notice is not served on the Managing

Director of the company. Hence, the service is not proper service. Issue

fresh notice to respondent personally and by post, and for counter

posted COP on 03.08.2020’.

3. This order is assailed on the ground that it is contrary to

Rule 2 Order XXIX of CPC, on the sole ground the petitioner sought

to set aside the impugned order. For better appreciation Rule 2

Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908 is extracted as

hereunder:-

Rule 2 Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908 "Service on

corporation"

Subject to any statutory provision regulating service of process,

where the suit is against a corporation, the summons may be served. 

2

(a) on the secretary, or on any director, or other principal officer of the

corporation, (or)

(b) by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the corporation at

the registered office, or if there is no registered office then at the

place where the corporation carries on business.

4. The dispute is only with regard to service of notice on the

respondent, but the order impugned in the Civil Revision Petition is

contrary to Rule 2 (b) Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908,

service by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the

corporation at the registered office, or if there is no registered office

then at the place where the corporation carries on business is self

sufficient service, is permitted by law.

5. Here, the petitioner complied with the procedure prescribed

under the Rule 2 (b) Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure 1908 by

sending notice to the registered office. Proof of service on the

registered office is also placed on record, but still the Special Judge

for trial of Commercial Disputes held that the service is not sufficient

and ordered fresh notice. The impugned order is apparently illegal

and contrary to Rule 2 (b) Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure

1908. On this ground alone the order is liable to be set aside.

6. During hearing learned counsel for the respondent fairly

conceded that the respondent will appear before the trial Court

even without sending the notice afresh and the same is recorded.


7. In view of our discussion the order under challenge is illegal

and contrary to Rule 2 (b) Order XXIX of Code of Civil Procedure

1908 and such order was passed by the Special Judge for trial of

Commercial Disputes, exceeding his jurisdiction. Hence, the order

impugned in this Civil Revision Petition is liable to be set aside. 

3

8. In the result, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed setting aside

the order dated 27.07.2020 in C.A.O.P.No.2 of 2020 passed by the

Special Judge for trial of Commercial Disputes, Ibrahimpatnam,

Vijayawada, while holding that the service of notice on the

respondent is sufficient, and the Special Judge for trial of

Commercial Disputes is directed to proceed in accordance with law.

No costs.

 Consequently miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall

also stand closed.

_________________________________________

JUSTICE M. SATYANARAYANA MURTHY

__________________________________

JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI

Date: 31.07.2020

IS 

4

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE M.SATYANARAYANA MURTHY

&

THE HON’BLE SMT JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI

CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.969 OF 2020

Date: 31-07-2020.

IS 

child custody order is to be executable but not by IA in the light of the specific direction to the respondent Nos.1 and 2 to hand over the minor child to the petitioner on attaining age of 5 years, this Court is of the opinion 4 that the petitioner is entitled for the custody of the minor child by name Pirati Dhanush. However, the petitioner has to follow the procedure provided under Section 18 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 for seeking custody of child. 11) Section 18 of The Family Courts Act, 1984 is extracted hereunder: 18. Execution of decrees and orders.- (1) A decree or an order [other than an order under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974)], passed by a Family Court shall have the same force and effect as a decree or order of a civil court and shall be executed in the same manner as is prescribed by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) for the execution of decrees and orders. -(1) A decree or an order [other than an order under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974)], passed by a Family Court shall have the same force and effect as a decree or order of a civil court and shall be executed in the same manner as is prescribed by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) for the execution of decrees and orders." (2) An order passed by a Family Court under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 5 1974) shall be executed in the manner prescribed for the execution of such order by that Code. (3) A decree or order may be executed either by the Family Court which passed it or by the other Family Court or ordinary civil court to which it is sent for execution. 12) In the light of the above provision of law, the petitioner has to file an application for execution of the order, dated 03.11.2017 before the Court below as per the procedure provided under law and the present application filed by the petitioner is not maintainable.

child custody order is to be executable but not by IA

 in the light of the specific direction to the respondent Nos.1 and 2 to hand over the minor child to the petitioner on attaining age of 5 years, this Court is of the opinion 4 that the petitioner is entitled for the custody of the minor child by name Pirati Dhanush. However, the petitioner has to follow the procedure provided under Section 18 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 for seeking custody of child. 11) Section 18 of The Family Courts Act, 1984 is extracted hereunder: 18. Execution of decrees and orders.- (1) A decree or an order [other than an order under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974)], passed by a Family Court shall have the same force and effect as a decree or order of a civil court and shall be executed in the same manner as is prescribed by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) for the execution of decrees and orders. -(1) A decree or an order [other than an order under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974)], passed by a Family Court shall have the same force and effect as a decree or order of a civil court and shall be executed in the same manner as is prescribed by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) for the execution of decrees and orders." (2) An order passed by a Family Court under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 5 1974) shall be executed in the manner prescribed for the execution of such order by that Code. (3) A decree or order may be executed either by the Family Court which passed it or by the other Family Court or ordinary civil court to which it is sent for execution. 12) In the light of the above provision of law, the petitioner has to file an application for execution of the order, dated 03.11.2017 before the Court below as per the procedure provided under law and the present application filed by the petitioner is not maintainable. 

AP HIGH COURT

 1

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND

CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO. 979 of 2020

Pirati Venkata Siva Vamsi Krishna,
Versus

Vanjarapu Appala Naidu

O R D E R:

This Civil Revision Petition is filed praying to direct the XIV

Additional District Judge-cum-Addl. Family Court, Vijayawada,

Krishna District to dispose of the I.A.No.95 of 2020 in

GWOP.No.578 of 2016 as expeditiously.

2) The petitioner filed GWOP No.578 of 2016 on the file of

the XIV Additional District Judge-cum-Addl. Family Court,

Vijayawada, Krishna District to declare and appoint the

petitioner as guardian for minor child by name Pirati Dhanush

directing the respondents 1 to 4 to give the said minor child to

the care and custody of the petitioner. Respondents 1 and 2

filed counter.

3) After hearing both counsel and upon appreciation of the

evidence available on record, the Court below partly allowed the

petition by its order, dated 03.11.2017 by declaring that the

petitioner is guardian of the minor child by name Pirati

Dhanush and directed the respondents 1 and 2 to hand over the

minor child to the petitioner on attaining the age of 5 years.

4) Seeking compliance of the order, dated 03.11.2017, the

petitioner filed I.A.No.95 of 2020 on 28.01.2020 before the Court

below seeking to appoint bailiff to hand over his minor son to 

 2

him with the help of amen/police aid from the custody of the

respondent Nos.1 and 2 since his child attained the age of 5

years on 19.01.2020. Aggrieved by the inaction of the Court

below in disposing the said application, present Civil Revision

Petition is filed.


5) Heard Sri B.V. Anjaneyulu, learned counsel for the

petitioner and Sri V.V. Rama Krishna, learned counsel for the

respondents.


6) Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as per the

order, dated 03.11.2017, the petitioner is entitled to take the

custody of the boy Pirati Dhanush as he attained age of 5 years.

It is submitted by the learned counsel that though the petitioner

filed I.A.No.95 of 2020 in the month of January, 2020, the Court

below simply adjourning the matter for counter of the

respondents. In fact, according to the learned counsel for the

petitioner, no counter is required as the respondents have to

hand over the custody of the body to the petitioner as per the

order, dated 03.11.2017 in G.W.O.P.No.578 of 2016. Learned

counsel further contended that as the Government has proposed

to reopen the schools in the first week of September, 2020 and

the petitioner intends to join his son into the school, he seeking

an early disposal of the I.A.No.95 of 2020. 

 3

7) On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents

submits that the interlocutory application filed by the petitioner

is not maintainable and the petitioner has to file execution

proceedings and sought custody of the child.

8) Having heard the submissions of both counsel and on

perusal of the material available on record, it appears that the

Court below by its order, dated 03.11.2017 in G.W.O.P.No.578

of 2016 passed very reasoned order declaring the petitioner as

guardian of the minor child. The Court below also directed the

respondent Nos.1 and 2 to hand over the minor child by name

Pirati Dhanush to the petitioner on attaining the age of 5 years.

9) Admittedly, as per the birth certificate issued by the

Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation which was filed as

material paper in the Civil Revision Petition, the date of birth of

the son of the petitioner by name Pirati Dhanush is 19.01.2015.

As such, as on the date of filing of the I.A.No.95 of 2020 i.e., on

28.01.2020, it is clearly established that the boy attained age of

5 years.

10) In the light of the categorical declaration made by the

Court below that the petitioner is guardian of the minor child by

name Pirati Dhanush and in the light of the specific direction to

the respondent Nos.1 and 2 to hand over the minor child to the

petitioner on attaining age of 5 years, this Court is of the opinion 

 4

that the petitioner is entitled for the custody of the minor child

by name Pirati Dhanush. However, the petitioner has to follow

the procedure provided under Section 18 of the Family Courts

Act, 1984 for seeking custody of child.


11) Section 18 of The Family Courts Act, 1984 is extracted

hereunder:

18. Execution of decrees and orders.-

(1) A decree or an order [other than an order under

Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973

(2 of 1974)], passed by a Family Court shall have the

same force and effect as a decree or order of a civil

court and shall be executed in the same manner as is

prescribed by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of

1908) for the execution of decrees and orders. -(1) A

decree or an order [other than an order under

Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973

(2 of 1974)], passed by a Family Court shall have the

same force and effect as a decree or order of a civil

court and shall be executed in the same manner as is

prescribed by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of

1908) for the execution of decrees and orders."

(2) An order passed by a Family Court under Chapter

IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 

 5

1974) shall be executed in the manner prescribed for

the execution of such order by that Code.

(3) A decree or order may be executed either by the

Family Court which passed it or by the other Family

Court or ordinary civil court to which it is sent for

execution.

12) In the light of the above provision of law, the petitioner has

to file an application for execution of the order, dated

03.11.2017 before the Court below as per the procedure

provided under law and the present application filed by the

petitioner is not maintainable.

13) Accordingly, this Civil Revision Petition is dismissed.

14) There is no order as to costs.

 As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this

petition shall stand closed.

______________________

JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND

Dt. 07.12.2020

PGR

or.39, rule 1 - as per the proceedings of Revenue Divisional officer, dated 20.09.2019, Pattadar pass book issued in favour of the petitioner was cancelled and his family member certificate was also cancelled and as such, he is not entitled for equitable relief of injunction. The petitioner as well as the respondents are claiming title over the petition schedule property. When there is a serious dispute with regard to the title between the parties, simple suit for permanent injunction is not maintainable. In these circumstances, it is not just and proper to grant temporary injunction in favour of the petitioner. Accordingly, the CMA was dismissed, vide order, dated 25.02.2020.

or.39, rule 1 - as per the proceedings of Revenue Divisional officer, dated 20.09.2019, Pattadar pass book issued in favour of the petitioner was cancelled and his family member certificate was also cancelled and as such, he is not entitled for equitable relief of injunction. The petitioner as well as the respondents are claiming title over the petition schedule property. When there is a serious dispute with regard to the title between the parties, simple suit for permanent injunction is not maintainable. In these circumstances, it is not just and proper to grant temporary injunction in favour of the petitioner. Accordingly, the CMA was dismissed, vide order, dated 25.02.2020. 

AP HIGH COURT

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE B.KRISHNA MOHAN

CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.982 of 2020

Gokapai Gandhi,
Versus

Bandi Karunakar,


ORDER:

 This Civil Revision Petition is filed challenging the

order in CMA No.8 of 2019 on the file of the Court of the IX Additional

District Judge, Machilipatnam, dated 25.02.2020 confirming the

order in I.A.No.738 of 2018 in O.S.103 of 2018, dated 16.07.2019 on

the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Avanigadda.

2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner.

3. The petitioner herein is the plaintiff in Original Suit No.103 of

2018 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Avanigadda. The said suit

is filed seeking permanent injunction against the defendants therein

with respect to item Nos.1 and 2 of the Plaint schedule property.

Pending suit, the petitioner also filed I.A.738 of 2018 before the Senior

Civil Judge, Avanigadda under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC and

Section 151 of CPC seeking to grant temporary injunction restraining

the respondents, their followers and successors from interfering with

the petition schedule property, contending that the petitioner’s father

said to have executed an unregistered Will, dated 19.11.2016

bequeathing the petition schedule property and he died later on

19.09.2017 and ever since, the petitioner has been in possession and

enjoyment of the petition schedule property. While so, the

respondents/defendants are trying to trespass into the schedule

property under the guise of a registered Will said to have been

executed by their father, dated 23.09.2016.

4. After hearing both the parties in I.A No.738 of 2018 and relying

upon the documents submitted before the trial court, the trial court 

2

came to a conclusion that the factum of possession would be decided

in the main suit and thus the petitioner has failed to establish his

prima-facie case and balance of convenience in his favour and as

such, the petitioner is not entitled for temporary injunction as prayed

for and there would be no irreparable loss to the petitioner, even if

temporary injunction is refused. Accordingly, the I.A.No.738 of 2018

was dismissed on 16.07.2019.

5. Aggrieved by the order in I.A.No.738 of 2018 in O.S.103 of 2018

on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Avanigadda, dated 16.07.2019,

the petitioner filed CMA No.8 of 2019 on the file of the IX Additional

District Judge, Machilipatnam, Krishna District.

6. After hearing both sides, the IX Additional District Judge,

Machilipatnam observed that as per the proceedings of Revenue

Divisional officer, dated 20.09.2019, Pattadar pass book issued in

favour of the petitioner was cancelled and his family member

certificate was also cancelled and as such, he is not entitled for

equitable relief of injunction. The petitioner as well as the respondents

are claiming title over the petition schedule property. When there is a

serious dispute with regard to the title between the parties, simple

suit for permanent injunction is not maintainable. In these

circumstances, it is not just and proper to grant temporary injunction

in favour of the petitioner. Accordingly, the CMA was dismissed, vide

order, dated 25.02.2020.

7. Aggrieved by the order of the IX Additional District Judge,

Machilipatnam, Krishna District in CMA No.8 of 2019, dated

25.02.2020, the present Civil Revision Petition is filed by the

petitioner. 

3

8. The learned counsel for the petitioner contends that before the

Courts below, there was an exparte injunction, upon filing the vacate

stay applications, on merits, the I.A was dismissed, since the suit

itself is for permanent injunction, the courts below ought not have

gone into the aspect of title to the property and denied grant of

injunction to the petitioner and sought for protection of the

possession.

9. Having regard to the facts and circumstances, since both the

Courts below have come to a conclusion on prima facie that the

petitioner could not establish his possession in the above said I.A.,

the relief could not be granted, unless the matter is further gone into

the merits with regard to the title and possession in the main suit. In

such circumstances, no temporary injunction can be granted at this

juncture and as such, this Court is not interfering with the orders of

the Courts below.

10. Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. However,

the trial Court is directed to proceed with the suit by giving due

opportunity to all the parties concerned as expeditiously as possible

and dispose of the same in accordance with law. There shall be no

order as to costs of the Civil Revision Petition.

 As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in

the Civil Revision Petition shall stand closed.

_______________________________

JUSTICE B. KRISHNA MOHAN

13.08.2020

mp 

under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, an appeal lies to a Court authorized by law to hear appeals from original decrees of the Court passing the order, against an order of Arbitral Tribunal either granting or refusing to grant a relief under Section 17 of the Act, 1996. 7. In this context, it would be appropriate to refer to the provisions of Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996. (1) An appeal shall lie from the following orders (and from no others) to the Court authorised by law to hear appeals from original decrees of the Court passing the order, namely:— (a) granting or refusing to grant any measure under section 9; (b) setting aside or refusing to set aside an arbitral award under section 34. (2) An appeal shall also lie to a Court from an order granting of the arbitral tribunal.— (a) accepting the plea referred in sub-section (2) or sub-section (3) of section 16; or (b) granting or refusing to grant an interim measure under section 17. (3) No second appeal shall lie from an order passed in appeal under this section, but nothing in this section shall affect or take away any right to appeal to the Supreme Court. 4 Admittedly, in the present case on hand, the petitioner herein filed Civil Miscellaneous Appeal before the court of the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ananthapuram against an order granted as an interim measure under Section 17 of the Act 1996. Therefore, rejection of the appeal filed by the petitioner herein by virtue of the impugned order (e filing order) dated 31.08.2020, in the considered opinion of this court, cannot be sustained.

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.V.SESHA SAI

AND

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.KRISHNA MOHAN

CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.1016 of 2020

ORDER:- (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice A.V.Sesha Sai)


Heard Sri P.V.S.A.Rama Murthy, learned counsel for the petitioner.

 2. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that

in pursuance of the orders of this court directing to take out personal

notice to the respondent, he had taken out the notice and filed proof of

service of the same in the Registry, vide USR No.30150 of 2020. In

support of the proof of service, a track report issued by the Department

of Posts showing the delivery of the item on 14.09.2020, is also filed by

the learned counsel for the petitioner in the Registry. Despite service of

the notice there is no appearance on behalf of the respondent.

3. The present Revision, instituted under Article 227 of the

Constitution of India, challenges the online order passed by the Court of

the Principal District Judge, Ananthapur, dated 31.08.2020 in e filing

No.CMA.69126 of 2020. The respondent herein filed Arbitration

Application No.5 of 2020 for arbitration of the dispute pertaining to nonpayment of loan instalments. Along with the said Arbitration

Application, the respondent herein also filed I.A.No.136 of 2020 under

Section 17 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, praying for

attachment of the immovable properties mentioned in the said

application. The learned Sole Arbitrator (Arbitral Tribunal), vide order

dated 03.08.2020, granted conditional attachment of the immovable 

 2

property under Section 17 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996

and the said order reads as follows :

 “In view of above facts, in exercise of the powers conferred

on me under Section 17 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act,

1996 do hereby order for the Conditional Attachment of

Immovable Property belonging to the Respondent as

mentioned under the schedule here under:

 Further the Respondent is hereby informed that if he

desires to have this attachment raised, and that the

respondent shall furnish cash security to the extent of the

claim amount of Rs.27,53,900/- by depositing the amount to

the claimant and producing the original challan / receipt

issued thereon to this Tribunal i.e., Sri M.Satyanarayana

Swamy, Arbitrator, Special Judicial Magistrate (Retd.),

H.No.5/178, Gowrav Residency, Alamur Road, Rudrampet,

Ananthapuram – 515004 on or before 05.09.2020 at 11.00

a.m. without fail for raising the attachment, if he fails to do

so within the stipulated period, this conditional attachment

shall be deemed to have been confirmed and made absolute

for the entire claim amount”.

 4. Aggrieved by the said order passed by the Sole Arbitrator on

03.08.2020, the petitioner herein preferred a Civil Miscellaneous Appeal

before the Court of the Principal District and Sessions Judge,

Ananthapuram under Order XLIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure,

1908 vide e filing case No.AP 2/CMA/69126/28.08.2020. The office of

the said Court rejected the said appeal and called upon as to how the

said case would be maintainable under Order XLIII Rule 1 of Code of

Civil Procedure, 1908.

 5. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the

Memorandum of Appeal in the aforesaid C.M.A. was represented on

31.08.2020 by mentioning the correct provision of law i.e., Section 37 of 

 3

the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The Court of the Principal

District and Sessions Judge, after the said re-submission of the appeal

by the petitioner, vide the impugned online order dated 31.08.2020,

made an endorsement that the case “already rejected”. In the above

back ground, the petitioner herein is before this Court with the present

revision under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

6. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri

P.V.S.A.Rama Murthy, is two fold in this regard. Firstly, he contends

that simply because a wrong provision of law is quoted in the

Memorandum of Grounds of the C.M.A., appeal ought not to have been

rejected by the Court of the Principal District and Sessions Judge when

there is a provision under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Secondly, it is strenuously contended by the learned counsel that under

Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, an appeal lies to

a Court authorized by law to hear appeals from original decrees of the

Court passing the order, against an order of Arbitral Tribunal either

granting or refusing to grant a relief under Section 17 of the Act, 1996.

7. In this context, it would be appropriate to refer to the

provisions of Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996.

(1) An appeal shall lie from the following orders (and from no others) to the

Court authorised by law to hear appeals from original decrees of the Court

passing the order, namely:—

(a) granting or refusing to grant any measure under section 9;

(b) setting aside or refusing to set aside an arbitral award under section 34.

(2) An appeal shall also lie to a Court from an order granting of the arbitral

tribunal.—

(a) accepting the plea referred in sub-section (2) or sub-section (3) of section

16; or

(b) granting or refusing to grant an interim measure under section 17.

(3) No second appeal shall lie from an order passed in appeal under this

section, but nothing in this section shall affect or take away any right to appeal

to the Supreme Court. 

 4

Admittedly, in the present case on hand, the petitioner herein filed

Civil Miscellaneous Appeal before the court of the Principal District and

Sessions Judge, Ananthapuram against an order granted as an interim

measure under Section 17 of the Act 1996. Therefore, rejection of the

appeal filed by the petitioner herein by virtue of the impugned order (e

filing order) dated 31.08.2020, in the considered opinion of this court,

cannot be sustained.

8. Accordingly the Civil Revision Petition is allowed, setting

aside the impugned online order dated 31.08.2020, rejecting the appeal

filed by the petitioner and the petitioner is granted two weeks’ time to represent the appeal before the Court of the learned Principal District and

Sessions Judge, Ananthapuram for consideration of the same by the

learned Principal District and Sessions Judge on merits. It is open for

the petitioner herein to file an appropriate application seeking

Interlocutory Order. The petitioner herein shall also comply with all

other requirements as per law. It is made clear that for a period of four

weeks from today, there shall be stay of further proceedings in

Arbitration Application No.5 of 2020 before the Sole Arbitrator (Arbitral

Tribunal). There shall be no order as to costs of the C.M.A.

Miscellaneous Applications pending, if any, in the C.M.A. shall

stand closed.

 _________________________

JUSTICE A.V.SESHA SAI

_________________________________

JUSTICE B.KRISHNA MOHAN

Date : 16.10.2020

Issue C.C.by 20.10.2020

b/o.

 sj 

 5


101


THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.V.SESHA SAI

AND

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.KRISHNA MOHAN


CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.1016 of 2020

Date : 16.10.2020

SJ 

Tuesday, February 2, 2021

An Appellate Court while dealing with an appeal against acquittal passed by the Learned trial Court, is required to bear in mind that in case of acquittal there is double presumption in favour of the accused. Firstly, the presumption of innocence is available to him under the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that every person shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved guilty by a competent court of law. Secondly, the accused having secured his acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is further 6 reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial Court. Therefore, while dealing with the cases of acquittal by the trial Court, the Appellate Court would have certain limitations.

 1

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.99 OF 2021

[Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 9105 of 2015]

State of Gujarat .. Appellant

Versus

Bhalchandra Laxmishankar Dave .. Respondent

J U D G M E N T

M. R. Shah, J.

Leave granted.

2. Feeling   aggrieved   and   dissatisfied   with   the   impugned

judgment and order dated 12.01.2015 passed by the High Court of

Gujarat in Criminal Appeal No.92 of 2003 by which the High Court

has   acquitted   the   respondent   herein   –   original   accused   for   the

offences under Section 7 read with Sections 13(1) & 13(2) of the

Prevention of Corruption Act  (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) by

2

quashing and setting aside the judgment and order of conviction

passed by the Learned Special Judge, Bharuch, the State of Gujarat

has preferred the present appeal.

3. The respondent herein – original accused (hereinafter referred

to as ‘the accused’) who was working as Assistant Director in ITI,

Gandhi   Nagar   was   charged   for   the   offences   punishable   under

Section 7 read with Sections 13(1) and 13(2) of the Act.

3.1 The Learned Special Judge, Bharuch after full­fledged trial

and appreciation of the entire evidence on record and by detailed

judgment and order convicted the accused under Section 7 read

with Sections 13(1) and 13(2) of the Act.  The Learned Special Judge

held the accused guilty and convicted the accused for the aforesaid

offences and imposed the sentence of 5 years imprisonment and

with fine of Rs.10,000/­.

3.2 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and order

of conviction and sentence passed by the Learned Special Judge in

Special A.C.B. Case No.14/2000 ­ the accused preferred appeal

before the High Court being Criminal Appeal No.92 of 2003.  By the

3

impugned judgment and order, the High Court without any detailed

re­appreciation of the entire evidence on record, has acquitted the

accused for the offences for which he was convicted.

4. Feeling   aggrieved   and   dissatisfied   with   the   impugned

judgment and order of acquittal passed by the High Court, the State

of Gujarat has preferred the present appeal.

5. We have heard Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Learned Advocate

appearing on behalf of State of Gujarat and Shri J.S. Attri, Learned

Senior   Advocate   and   Shri   Haresh   Raichura,   Learned   Advocate

appearing on behalf of respondent – accused.

5.1. Number of submissions have been made by learned counsels

of the respective parties.   However, for the reasons stated herein

below, we propose to remand the matter to the High Court, any

observation made by this Court may affect either the prosecution or

the defence, we refrain from dealing with the submissions made by

the Learned counsels appearing on behalf of the respective parties

on merits.

4

6. We have gone through the detailed judgment and order of

conviction passed by the Learned Trial Court and also the evidence

on record laid down by the prosecution as well as the defence. We

have perused the impugned judgment and order of acquittal passed

by   the   High   Court   to   ascertain   whether   the   High   Court   has

conformed to the principles while exercising in the criminal appeal

against the judgment and order of conviction.   We find that the

High Court has not strictly proceeded in the manner in which High

Court ought to have while dealing with the appeal against the order

of conviction.  On perusal of the impugned judgment and order of

acquittal passed by the High Court, we find that, as such, there is

no re­appreciation of the entire evidence on record in detail while

acquitting the respondent – accused.   The High Court has only

made   general   observations   on   the   depositions   of   the   witnesses

examined.     However,   there   is   no   re­appreciation   of   the   entire

evidence on record in detail, which ought to have been done by the

High Court while dealing with the judgment and order of conviction

passed by the Learned Trial Court.

5

6.1 The High Court ought to have appreciated that it was dealing

with the first appeal against the order of conviction passed by the

Learned trial Court.   Being First Appellate Court, the High Court

was required to re­appreciate the entire evidence on record and also

the reasoning given by the Learned trial Court while convicting the

accused.  Non­re­appreciation of the evidence on record may affect

the case of either the prosecution or even the accused.  Being the

First Appellate Court the High Court ought to have re­appreciated

the entire evidence on record without any limitation, which might

be there while dealing with an appeal against the order of acquittal

passed by the Learned Trial Court.

6.2 An   Appellate   Court   while   dealing   with   an   appeal   against

acquittal passed by the Learned trial Court, is required to bear in

mind that in case of acquittal there is double presumption in favour

of the accused.  Firstly, the presumption of innocence is available to

him under the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that

every person shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved

guilty by a competent court of law.  Secondly, the accused having

secured his acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is further

6

reinforced,   reaffirmed   and   strengthened   by   the   trial   Court.

Therefore, while dealing with the cases of acquittal by the trial

Court, the Appellate Court would have certain limitations.  Even in

the case of acquittal passed by the Learned Trial Court, in the case

of Umedbhai Jadavbhai vs. The State of Gujarat, (1978) 1 SCC

228, it is observed and held by this Court that “Once the appeal is

entertained against the order of acquittal, the High Court is entitled

to re­appreciate the entire evidence independently and come to its

own   conclusion.     Ordinarily,   the   High   Court   would   give   due

importance to the opinion of the Sessions Judge if the same were

arrived at after proper appreciation of the evidence.  The High Court

would be justified against an acquittal passed by the Learned Trial

Court even on re­appreciation of the entire evidence independently

and   come   to   its   own   conclusion   that   acquittal   is   perverse   and

manifestly erroneous”.   However, so far as the appeal against the

order of conviction is concerned, there are no such restrictions and

the Court of appeal has wide powers of appreciation of evidence and

the High Court has to re­appreciate the entire evidence on record

being  a   First  Appellate  Court.     Keeping   in  mind  that   once   the

7

Learned Trial Court has convicted there shall not be presumption of

innocence as would be there in the case of acquittal.

7. On perusal of the impugned judgment and order of acquittal

passed by the High Court, we find that High Court decision is based

on   totally   erroneous   view   of   law   by   ignoring   the   settled   legal

position.   The approach of the High Court in dealing/non­dealing

with the evidence was patently illegal leading to grave miscarriage of

justice.   Therefore, we are of the firm opinion that the impugned

judgment   and   order   passed   by   the   High   Court   acquitting   the

respondent – accused without adverting to the reasons given by the

Learned trial Court while convicting the accused and without reappreciating   the   entire   evidence   on   record   in   detail   cannot   be

sustained and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside.  We

are of the opinion that therefore matter deserves to be remanded to

the High Court to consider and deal with the appeal afresh in

accordance with law and on its own merits keeping in mind the

observations made hereinabove.   The High Court ought to have

8

appreciated   that   it   was   dealing   with   the   offences   under   the

Prevention of Corruption Act which offences are against the society.

And therefore the High Court ought to have been more careful and

ought to have gone in detail.   We do not approve the manner in

which the High Court has dealt with the appeal.

8. In view of the above and for the reasons stated hereinabove

and without expressing anything on merits of the case, the present

appeal   is   allowed.   The   impugned   judgment   and   order   dated

12.01.2015 in Criminal Appeal No.92 of 2003 passed by the High

Court acquitting the accused for the offences under the Act for

which he was tried is hereby quashed and set aside.  The appeal

before the High Court is restored to its original file.  The High Court

to decide and dispose of the appeal in accordance with law and on

its own merits bearing in mind the observations made hereinabove.

At the cost of repetition we observe that we have not expressed

anything   on   merits  in   favour  of   either   prosecution   or  even   the

9

accused and the High Court to decide and dispose of the appeal on

its own merits as observed hereinabove.

.……………………………J.

(ASHOK BHUSHAN)

……………………………J.

(R. SUBHASH REDDY)

……………………………J.

(M. R. SHAH)

New Delhi,

February 2, 2021.