About Me

My photo
since 1985 practicing as advocate in both civil & criminal laws. This blog is only for information but not for legal opinions

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

award the compensation at the rate of Rs.2,50,000/- per acre together with all statutory benefits. = the valuation of the lands of Suraram village as reflected from Exs.A.3 to A.5, particularly in view of the fact that the Land Acquisition Officer had fixed the market value at the rate of Rs.1.30,000/- per acre in respect of the land belonging to some of the claimants, who gave consent for acquisition, the reference Court held that the market value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer at the rate of Rs.46,500/- per acre was absolutely low and inadequate and accordingly thought it fit to award the compensation at the rate of Rs.2,50,000/- per acre together with all statutory benefits.


THE HONOURABLE Ms. JUSTICE

G. ROHINI

and

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE

C.PRAVEEN KUMAR


 LAAS Nos.161/2011 & cross objections
LAAS Nos.162/2011 & cross objections
LAAS Nos.213/2011 & cross objections
LAAS Nos.323/2011 & cross objections


COMMON JUDGMENT

                   (per the Honourable Ms. Justice G. ROHINI)

          These four appeals are filed by the A.P. Power Generation Corporation Ltd., represented by its Authorized Signatory, Hyderabad, under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short “the Act”) aggrieved by the common order dated 26.03.2010 passed by the Court of the Principal Senior Civil Judge at Kothagudem (herein after referred to as the ‘reference Court’) in LAOP.Nos.1 to 4 of 2010 contending that the enhanced compensation awarded by the reference Court at the rate of Rs.2,50,000/- per acre is excessive and not based on the evidence available on record. 
On the other hand, the respondents/claimants in all the OPs filed cross objections with a prayer to grant further enhancement as per the claim made by them i.e. at the rate of Rs.5,00,000/- per acre.
          We have heard Sri C.Raghu, the learned counsel for the appellants and Sri Hari Sreedhar, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents/cross objectors. 
          As could be seen from the material available on record, the land belonging to the respondents-claimants  situated in Suraramvillage of Paloncha Mandal was acquired for the purpose of construction of Northern ash  pond of Kothagudem Thermal Power Station O &  M (V Stage) by notification dated 02.05.2006 published under Section 4(1) of the Act.  After due enquiry, the Land Acquisition Officer passed an award on 23-6-2009 being award No.1/2009 fixing the market value at the rate of Rs.46,500/- per acre. Not being satisfied with the quantum of compensation awarded, the claimants sought reference under Section 18 of the Act and thus OP Nos.1, 2, 3 and 4 of 2010 have been taken up by the reference Court.
On behalf of the claimants, P.Ws.1 to 7 were examined before the reference court and Exs.A-1 to A-9 documents were marked to substantiate their claim. None was examined on behalf of the Referring Officer, however, Ex.B-1-award dated 23.06.2009 was marked.
On appreciation of the said evidence, the reference Court enhanced the compensation for the land acquired from Rs.46,500/- per acre to Rs.2,50,000/- per acre together with 30% solatium on the enhanced market value and 12% additional market value from the date of taking possession. The reference Court also awarded interest at 9% per annum on the enhanced market value for the first oneyear  and at 15% per annum thereafter. So far as the fruit bearing trees are concerned, the reference Court declined to grant any enhancement and whatever compensation was awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer was confirmed. 
Aggrieved by the said order of the reference Court dated 26.03.2010, A.P. Power Generation Company Ltd., preferred the present four appeals contending that the enhancement granted is exorbitant and without any basis. On behalf of the claimants-respondents, cross-objections have been filed claiming enhancement of compensation at the rate of Rs.5 lakhs per acre.
Out of the documents marked before the reference Court, the reference Court relied upon Ex.A.3, which is the market value certificate issued by the Sub-Registrar (Registrations), Kothagudem showing the market value of the land in Sy.No.68/1 and 69/1 ofSuraram village as well as Exs.A.4 and A.5-valuation certificates showing the market value of the land during the years 2004 and 2006.  It is relevant to note that Suraram village being an agency area, no registered sale deeds were available with regard to the sale transactions in the said village.  However, the claimants produced Exs.A-6-certified copy of registered sale deed dated 31.03.2005 and Ex.A-7-certified copy of registered sale deed dated 21.08.2006 related to the land situated in a different village, namely, Paloncha, stating that the land covered by the Exs.A.6 and A.7 sale deeds is situated only one kilo meter away from the acquired land.  
In the light of the valuation of the lands of Suraram village as reflected from Exs.A.3 to A.5, particularly in view of the fact that the Land Acquisition Officer had fixed the market value at the rate of Rs.1.30,000/- per acre in respect of the land belonging to some of the claimants, who gave consent for acquisition, the reference Court held that the market value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer at the rate of Rs.46,500/- per acre was absolutely low and inadequate and accordingly thought it fit to award the compensation at the rate of Rs.2,50,000/- per acre together with all statutory benefits. 
However, it is contended by the respondents/cross objectors that though Exs.A.6 and A.7 sale transactions related to the land situated in a different village, namely Paloncha since it is situated only one kilo meter away from the acquired land, the reference Court ought to have taken the consideration under the said sale deeds as the basis for fixing the compensation.   
 It is to be noticed that under Ex.A.6 sale deed, a house plot admeasuring 365 square yards was sold for a consideration of Rs.1,50,000/- on 31.03.2005 whereas, under Ex.A.7 sale deed, an extent of 260.66 square yards of house site was sold for Rs.2,67,000/- on 21.08.2006.  
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that on conversion of the said consideration into acreage basis, the market value would come to Rs.409.83 per square yard i.e. Rs. 19,83,577/- per acre and therefore the reference Court ought to have granted atleast Rs.5,00,000/- per acre after giving the necessary deductions towards developmental charges. 
In the light of the evidence available on record and reasons assigned by the reference Court, we are of the opinion that the compensation awarded by the reference Court at Rs.2,50,000/- per acre is just and reasonable.   
Though in the cross objections filed by them the respondents claimed the compensation at the rate of Rs.5,00,000/- per acre on the basis of Exs.A.6 and A.7, in view of the fact that the said house sites are situated in a different village, Paloncha, which is an industrial area, whereas the acquired land is situated in a tribal area, we are not inclined to rely upon the same for granting further enhancement.  In our considered opinion, the reference Court was justified in awarding the compensation at the rate of Rs.2,50,000/- per acre and the same is based on proper appreciation of the evidence available on record.   Therefore, the interference by us is not warranted on any ground whatsoever. 
For the aforesaid reasons both the appeals and the cross-objections are dismissed confirming the order under appeal passed bythe  reference Court. No order as to costs.
                                                                   ______________                                                                                          G. ROHINI,J.

______________________
 C. PRAVEEN KUMAR, J.        
Date: 13-12-2012
Kmr/KLP

a prime locality, they have potential value.enhanced from Rs.65/-to Rs.150/-per square yard, = Though the transactions covered under Exs.A5 and A6 are not comparable sales, admittedly, the acquired land is situated at a distance of 1 ½ furlong from Secunderabad to Karimnagar road at Alwal. The admitted fact that the lands were acquired for the purpose of providing house sites to the weaker sections of the society and are situated in a prime locality, they have potential value. In view of the escalation of prices within the vicinity of Hyderabad and as the acquired land is situated near to the main road, we are of the view that the market value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer, as confirmed by the Court below, is meagre and therefore, the claimants are entitled to enhancement of the market value.

LAAS 758 / 2011

LAASSR 828 / 2011

PETITIONERRESPONDENT
D.VITTAL RAO AND 32 OTHERS  VSDEPUTY DIRECTOR OF SOCIAL WELFARE & LAO, HYDERABAD AND OTHER
PET.ADV. : SRIDHARRESP.ADV. : 
SUBJECT: LAND ACQUISITION SUITSDISTRICT:  HYDERABAD
FILING DATE:  29-01-2011POSTING STAGE :  FOR JUDGMENTDISPOSED ON  :  29-03-2012  PANC
REG. DATE    :   25-08-2011LISTING DATE :  29-03-2012STATUS   :  ---------
HON'BLE JUDGE(S):GHULAM MOHAMMED    

THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE GHULAM MOHAMMED
AND

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.S.APPA RAO

 

L.A.A.S.Nos.74 of 2010 and 758 of 2011

 

 

COMMON JUDGMENT (Per the Hon’ble Sri Justice Ghulam Mohammed)

           

Since both these appeals are filed against the order of dismissal dated 28.01.2002 passed in O.P.No.393 of 1989 by the learned First Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, they are being taken up together for disposal by this common judgment.  In LAAS No.758 of 2011, the appellants are represented by their GPA holder.

2.       The facts, in brief, are that in pursuance of the notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short ‘the Act’), dated 12.05.1979, the land admeasuring Ac.4.33 gts equivalent to 23353 sq. yards in Sy.No.9 of East Marredpally village, was acquired by the Government for the purpose of providing house sites to Scheduled Castes, Backward Classes and other weaker sections of the society.  
After service of notices to the claimants, 
the Land Acquisition Officer had conducted enquiry and fixed the market value at Rs.65/-per square yard by considering nine sale transactions in the vicinity took place during the years 1977 to 1979. Having not satisfied with the said market value, the claimants filed petitions, and thereupon the matter was referred to the civil Court.

3.       The claimants filed claim statement stating that as 
the acquired land is situated near to the main road leading from Secunderabad to Alwal i.e., Karimangar, which is a commercial highway, near to ACC Centre and the surrounding areas have already been built up as on the date of draft notification, the market value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer is meagre, unfair and unjust.  
Hence, they prayed to enhance the compensation from Rs.65/- to Rs.500/-per square yard.

4.       During the course of trial, P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.A1 to A8 were got marked on behalf of the claimants.  R.W.1 was examined and Exs.B1 to B3 were got marked on behalf of the referring officer.  
The Court below after considering the evidence adduced by the parties and the material on record, dismissed the O.P. confirming the market value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer at Rs.65/-per square yard. Aggrieved by the same, the claimants filed the present appeals.

5.     Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants contended that the Court below has failed to fix the correct market value of the land acquired, which is situated near to the main road leading from Secunderabad to Alwal and is fully developed with residential houses, and it erroneously dismissed the O.P.

6.   Learned Government Pleader for Appeals contended that the Court below after considering the evidence adduced and the material documents has rightly dismissed the O.P., by the order impugned, which needs no interference by this Court.

7.     Now, the point for consideration is 
whether the claimants are entitled to enhancement of the market value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer?

8.    The Government had acquired the land to an extent of Ac.4.33 gts situated in Sy.No.9 of East Marredpally village, belonging to the claimants, and after due enquiry, the Land Acquisition Officer has fixed the market value at Rs.65/-per square yard vide award dated 23.01.1988.  
The claimants had mainly relied upon the sale transactions covered under Exs.A5 to A8. They state that the properties covered under Exs.A5 and A6 were sold at Rs.200/- and Rs.227/-per square yard, respectively. 
Exs.A7 and A8 are the connected certificates. 
The Court below held that the properties under Exs.A5 and A6 are neither adjacent nor within the vicinity of the acquired land in Sy.No.9, to rely upon the same and they are house properties.

9.     Though the transactions covered under Exs.A5 and A6 are not comparable sales, admittedly, the acquired land is situated at a distance of 1 ½ furlong from Secunderabad to Karimnagar road at Alwal.  The admitted fact that the lands were acquired for the purpose of providing house sites to the weaker sections of the society and are situated in a prime locality, they have potential value.  In view of the escalation of prices within the vicinity of Hyderabad and as the acquired land is situated near to the main road, we are of the view that the market value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer, as confirmed by the Court below, is meagre and therefore, the claimants are entitled to enhancement of the market value.

10.    In the facts and circumstances of the case, the market value of the acquired lands fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer is enhanced from Rs.65/-to Rs.150/-per square yard, which is just and proper. The claimants are entitled to all the statutory benefits as awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer and also as per the amended Act.

11.    Accordingly, both the appeals are allowed in part. The impugned order dated 28.01.2002 passed in O.P.No.393 of 1989 is set aside. Consequently, O.P.No.393 of 1989 stands allowed to the extent indicated above. No costs.
                                                                                                   
_____________________
          GHULAM MOHAMMED, J


_______________

K.S.APPA RAO, J

Date:29.03.2012
sj

valid license for doing money lending business = once the execution of pronote is admitted, the presumption under Section 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 would be drawn. If it is drawn, the presumption is that it is supported by consideration. Of course, it is a rebuttable presumption. The defendants can rebut the said presumption by adducing necessary evidence that Ex.A-1 was not supported by consideration. No such evidence was adduced by the defendants to rebut the burden placed on them. Therefore, the point is answered accordingly. ;whether the plaintiff is having valid license to do money lending business or not, Ex.A-11 is the certified copy of Certificate of Registration issued by the Registrar of Firms in the name of ‘Maruthi Finance Corporation’. Later, it was changed as ‘Maruthi Hire Purchase and Financiers’ with effect from 01.10.1995. The plaint was filed in the changed name of the plaintiff. P.W.1, in the cross examination, also stated that they have money lending license under the name and style of the plaintiff. Ex.A-12, license, is valid upto 04.10.1995. Execution of Ex.A-1 is prior to Ex.A-12.


                            IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE, ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD


                        PRESENT

                        THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.C.BHANU


A.S.No.685 OF 2011

           Date:09.09.2011



Between:-


N.Govardhan Reddy

      ..Appellant
And

Maruthi Hire Purchase and Financers, Hanamkonda and another

     .. Respondents







 

JUDGMENT:-



This appeal, under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, is directed against the judgment and decree, dated 31.03.2003, in O.S.No.352 of 1995 on the file of the Principal Senior Civil Judge, Warangal.

2.          Heard.

3.      The case of plaintiff is that it is doing money lending business.  Defendant No.1 borrowed a sum of Rs.2,50,000/- from plaintiff agreeing to repay the same with interest at 30% p.a. and executed a promissory note, dated 04.09.1995, in favour of the plaintiff. Defendant No.2 stood as guarantor and executed a guarantee bond in favour of the plaintiff.  On demand, defendant No.1 issued two post dated cheques, dated 11.11.1995 and 09.12.1995, for Rs.1,50,000/- and Rs.1,00,000/- respectively. 
At request of defendant No.1, first cheque was not presented at the given date and both the cheques were presented for clearance on 10.12.1995, but both the cheques were returned as bounced.  
The plaintiff issued a notice to defendant No.1 and reserves its right to initiate criminal prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. As defendant No.2 also failed to respond on the demands of the plaintiff, plaintiff issued legal notice, dated 18.12.1995, to both the defendants, but there was no response.  Hence, the suit.

4.          Defendant No.1 filed a detailed written statement denying all the averments made in the plaint.  It was stated that the plaintiff did not furnish the statement of account intimating the alleged liability before filing the suit.  He had no occasion to reply the plaintiff’s alleged demand at any time.  The plaintiff did not choose to submit the accounts into Court, which belies the suit transaction. Defendant No.2 is not concerned with him in any transaction.  Father of defendant No.2 has been the partner along with defendant No.1 in M/s.Radhakrishna Traders.  At the instance of father of defendant No.2, defendant No.2 has been allowed to work in the firm as a Gumastha but defendant No.2 has no independent authority to transact on behalf of the firm.  On account of unauthorized activities of defendant No.2 in the said firm, the business suffered heavy loss and the firm was closed.  So, availing of loan by defendant Nos.1 and 2 and executing the documents does not arise.  As defendant No.2 started abusing the affairs of the firm, defendant No.1 addressed their banker on 04.09.1995 not to honour any cheque of their firm since defendant No.1 is not operating the business and management affairs.  Even if defendant No.1 availed any loan from plaintiff in the name of the firm, the same is unauthorized and it is not by defendant No.1.  Defendant No.1 did not avail any amount from plaintiff firm at any point of time and it is false that defendant No.1 executed the pronote on 14.09.1995 binding himself for and on behalf of firm M/s.Radhakrishna Traders for a sum of Rs.2,50,000/-. Similarly, the alleged issue of two cheques by defendant No.1 is not true and correct.  He does not owe any amount to the plaintiff in any capacity.  The alleged pronote and cheques are outcome of collusion between defendant No.2 and plaintiff and hence, prays to dismiss the suit with compensatory costs to defendant No.1.

5.          Defendant No.2 filed his written statement denying the averments in the plaint and stated that the plaintiff is a stranger and imposter and there was no relation at any point of time pertaining to money lending business between himself and plaintiff.  The plaintiff, in collusion with defendant No.1, forged and fabricated the document through which the speculative suit was filed.  He never approached the plaintiff nor borrowed a sum of Rs.2,50,000/- and agreed to pay the same with interest at 30% p.a. and executed a pronote on 14.09.1995 and he stood as guarantor and executed a guarantee bond in favour of the plaintiff. He does not know about the alleged borrowal and whether defendant No.1 issued any post dated cheques for Rs.1,50,000/- and Rs.1,00,000/- as alleged in the plaint, that they were bounced and a notice was issued.  No notice was served on him and hence, the question of responding does not arise. He came to know about the alleged suit claim through the summons.  He worked under defendant No.1 from 1985 to 1996 in his shop-Sri Radhakrishna Traders at Grain Market, Warangal as a Gumastha on salary basis and there were some disputes between him and defendant No.1.  Defendant No.1, in collusion with plaintiff, hatched a plan on false grounds and might have forged his signature to fulfil their desires.  The suit was filed for wrongful gain and liable to be dismissed with costs.

6.          Basing on the above pleadings, the following issues have been framed for trial:
1.      Whether the suit pronote, dated 14.09.1995, is true, valid and supported by consideration?

2.      Whether defendants 1 and 2 issued post dated cheques, dated 11.11.1995 and 09.12.1995, in favour of plaintiff?

3.      To what relief?


7.       On behalf of the plaintiff, P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and marked Exs.A-1 to A-13.  On behalf of the defendants, D.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.B-1 to B-3 were marked.

8.       The trial Court, after considering the oral and documentary evidence available on record, decreed the suit with costs. Challenging the same, defendant No.1 filed this appeal.

9.          Learned counsel for the appellant/defendant No.1 contended that the plaintiff is not having a valid license for doing money lending business; that no corresponding documents were filed viz., statement of account to show that the amount covered by the pronote was being paid to defendant No.1 by the plaintiff, and therefore, he prays to set aside the impugned judgment.

10.          Learned counsel for the respondent No.1/plaintiff contended that Ex.A-11 is the certified copy of the certificate of registration of firm issued by the Registrar of Firms, which clearly shows that plaintiff is having a valid license to do the money lending business; that execution of Ex.A-1-pronote, dated 14.09.1995, was not denied or disputed by the defendant and therefore, the presumption is that it is supported by consideration and hence, there are no grounds to interfere with the impugned judgment and prays to sustain the same.

11.     Now the points for determination are:
          1)Whether the suit pronote, dated 14.09.1995, is true,
             valid and supported by consideration? and

          2) Whether the plaintiff is having a valid license to do     
              money lending business?

12.     Point No.1:- P.W.1, who is the Managing Partner of plaintiff firm, has categorically stated that he lent an amount of Rs.2,50,000/- to defendant No.1 on 14.09.1995 and thereafter, defendant No.1 executed the promissory note.  The plaintiff also examined P.W.2, who is the attestor to Ex.A-1.  The evidence of attestor would also go to show that defendant No.1 executed the promissory note.  Nothing has been elicited in their cross examination to disbelieve the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2.  Their evidence leave no room to doubt about execution of Ex.A-1 promissory note by defendant No.1 and receipt of consideration thereon.  Therefore, the trial Court placed an implicit reliance on the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2.  
D.W.1 did not dispute or deny about the execution of Ex.A-1 promissory note. Therefore, once the execution of pronote is admitted, the presumption under Section 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 would be drawn.  If it is drawn, the presumption is that it is supported by consideration.  
Of course, it is a rebuttable presumption.  The defendants can rebut the said presumption by adducing necessary evidence that Ex.A-1 was not supported by consideration.  No such evidence was adduced by the defendants to rebut the burden placed on them.  Therefore, the point is answered accordingly. 

13.     Point No.2:- Coming to the second point as to 
whether the plaintiff is having valid license to do money lending business or not, Ex.A-11 is the certified copy of Certificate of Registration issued by the Registrar of Firms in the name of ‘Maruthi Finance Corporation’. 
Later, it was changed as ‘Maruthi Hire Purchase and Financiers’ with effect from 01.10.1995.  
The plaint was filed in the changed name of the plaintiff.  
P.W.1, in the cross examination, also stated that they have money lending license under the name and style of the plaintiff.  Ex.A-12, license, is valid upto 04.10.1995.  Execution of Ex.A-1 is prior to Ex.A-12.  Hence, this ground is not available to defendant No.1.  Therefore, the contention of learned counsel for defendant No.1 on this aspect is untenable.  Hence, there are no grounds to interfere with the impugned judgment, and the appeal is devoid of merit is liable to be dismissed.
         
14.     The Appeal Suit is, accordingly, dismissed.  There shall be no order as to costs.

_­­­_____________________

JUSTICE K.C.BHANU

09th September, 2011
AMD



THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.C.BHANU







































A.S.No.685 OF 2011
















           Date:09.09.2011







AMD

Monday, January 28, 2013

refusing to receive and register the sale deed for the land in an extent of Ac.4.01 cents in Sy.No.743 of Gadela village, Obulavaripalli Mandal, Cuddapah District, though the same was purchased by the 1st petitioner in the public auction conducted by the 4th respondent in pursuance of the proceedings in E.P.No.576/96-97, as arbitrary, illegal, contrary to the provisions of the A.P. Assigned lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977 and also the law laid down by this Hon’ble Court in W.A.No.950 of 2007 apart from being violative of the fundamental and constitutional rights guaranteed under Articles 14,19, 21 & 300A of the Constitution of India and consequently direct the respondent No.3 to receive and register the sale deed for the above said land and to pass such other order or orders as this Hon’ble Court deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.” -since petitioner No.1 has purchased the assigned land in a public auction held for recovery of dues owed to a co-operative society, the case is covered by the judgment in Sub Registrar, Srikalahasti, Chittoor District v. K. Guravaiah[1].




The Hon'ble Sri Justice C.V.Nagarjuna Reddy

 

Writ Petition No.1363 of 2013

 

Dated:22.01.2013

 

Between:

 


Smt.Basetti Subbaratnamma and others             … Petitioners

And


The Government of Andhra Pradesh,
Represented by its Principal Secretary,
Revenue Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad and others                                           … Respondents

                                                                        

Counsel for the petitioners                : Sri Balaji Medamalli



Counsel for respondents          : Assistant Government Pleader for
                                                 Revenue              

 









 

 




The Court made the following :







ORDER:
          This writ petition is filed for the following substantive relief:
“to issue a writ, order or direction, more particularly one in the nature of a Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondent No.3 in refusing to receive and register the sale deed for the land in an extent of Ac.4.01 cents in Sy.No.743 of Gadela village, Obulavaripalli Mandal, Cuddapah District, though the same was purchased by the 1st petitioner in the public auction conducted by the 4th respondent in pursuance of the proceedings in E.P.No.576/96-97, as arbitrary, illegal, contrary to the provisions of the A.P. Assigned lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977 and also the law laid down by this Hon’ble Court in W.A.No.950 of 2007 apart from being violative of the fundamental and constitutional rights guaranteed under Articles 14,19, 21 & 300A of the Constitution of India and consequently direct the respondent No.3 to receive and register the sale deed for the above said land and to pass such other order or orders as this Hon’ble Court deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.”

          At the hearing, it is conceded by the learned Assistant Government Pleader for Revenue thatsince petitioner No.1 has purchased the assigned land in a public auction held for recovery of dues owed to a co-operative society, the case is covered by the judgment in Sub Registrar, Srikalahasti, Chittoor District v. K. Guravaiah[1].

In the light of the above, the writ petition is allowed with the direction to respondent No.3 to receive the document(s) that may be presented by the petitioners and register the same, subject to the latter complying with the provisions of the Registration Act, 1908 and the Indian Stamp Act, 1899.

As a sequel to disposal of the Writ Petition, W.P.M.P.No.1645 of 2013 filed by the petitioners for interim relief is disposed of as infructuous.

_____________________________

C.V.NAGARJUNA REDDY, J

22.01.2013
KH

Sunday, January 27, 2013

refusing to receive and register the sale deed sought to be presented by the petitioners only on the ground that the Resurvey and Settlement Register (RSR) contained dots is questioned in this Writ Petition. This Court repeatedly held that mere entry in the RSR will not constitute conclusive proof of title. Therefore, respondent No.4 is directed to receive the document sought to be presented by the petitioners for registration without reference to the dots in the RSR and process the same under Section 71 of the Registration Act, 1908.


HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.NAGARJUNA REDDY

WRIT PETITION No.474 of 2013

Dated 04.01.2013
Between:

Mekala Pedda Venkata Subbaiah
And another.
          …Petitioners

And


The State of A.P., reptd by its
District Collector, Y.S.R.Kadapa District,
and three others.
          …Respondents

Counsel for the petitioners: Sri V.R.Reddy Kovvuri
                                              
Counsel for the respondents: AGP for Revenue

 

The Court made the following:





                                                                                    







ORDER:                           
Action of respondent No.4 in refusing to receive and register the sale deed sought to be presented by the petitioners only on the ground that the Resurvey and Settlement Register (RSR) contained dots is questioned in this Writ Petition.
This Court repeatedly held that mere entry in the RSR will not constitute conclusive proof of title. Therefore, respondent No.4 is directed to receive the document sought to be presented by the petitioners for registration without reference to the dots in the RSR and process the same under Section 71 of the Registration Act, 1908.
If respondent No.4 has legally sustainable reasons for the refusal to register the document, he shall pass an order giving reasons therefor and communicate the same to the petitioners, and conversely, he shall register the document (s) that may be presented by the petitioners subject to the petitioners complying with the provisions of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and the Registration Act, 1908. He shall complete this exercise within a period of one month from the date of receipt of the document/s from the petitioners.
Subject to the above directions, the Writ Petition is disposed of.
As a sequel, W.P.M.P.No.585 of 2013 is dismissed as infructuous.

__________________________

JUSTICE C.V.NAGARJUNA REDDY

04thJanuary, 2013             
dr

the mere classification of land as Assessed Waste and the entry in the revenue record that it belongs to the Government do not determine the title and that the Registrar cannot ignore ownership of the party by giving weight to mere entries in the revenue record. In the instant case, the petitioner has traced the legal title through the document as far back as 21.5.1918 and enumerated the details relating to as many as 12 transitions through registered sale deeds commencing from 21.05.1918 up to 12.03.1995. In the face of this overwhelming documentary evidence showing that the property is a private property which changed hands through registered sale deeds on as many as 12 occasions, there is no justification for respondent No.3 to place reliance on the entry in the revenue record describing the property as Assessed Waste and refusing to receive and register the document on that basis.


WP 343 / 2013

WPSR 170 / 2013

PETITIONERRESPONDENT
VASANTHAMMA BANKAPURAM,KADAPA DIST  VSTHE DIST.COLLECTOR,KADAIA & 2 OTHERS
PET.ADV. : APARNA LAKSHMIRESP.ADV. : GP FOR REVENUE
SUBJECT: STAMPS & REGISTRATIONDISTRICT:  CUDDAPAH
FILING DATE:  02-01-2013POSTING STAGE :  ADMISSION (STAMPS AND REGISTRATION )DISPOSED ON  :  04-01-2013  ANC
REG. DATE    :   03-01-2013LISTING DATE :  04-01-2013STATUS   :  ---------
HON'BLE JUDGE(S):C.V.NAGARJUNA REDDY    


HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.NAGARJUNA REDDY

WRIT PETITION No.343 OF 2013
Dated 04-01-2013
Between :-
Vasanthamma Bankapuram                                        
……..Petitioner
And
The District Collector and Magistrate
Kadapa District and two others                              
………Respondents

 

Counsel for the Petitioner      : Sri B.V.Aparna Lakshmi
Counsel for the Respondents  : Assistant Government Pleader
                                                              for Revenue
                                                          

The Court made the following:-







O R D E R:
This Writ Petition is filed for a Mandamus to declare the action of respondent No.3 in refusing to receive and register the document sought to be presented by the petitioner on the ground that the property in question is an Assessed Waste, as illegal and arbitrary.
At the hearing, it is agreed by the learned Assistant Government Pleader for Revenue that this Court in W.P.No.11332 of 2010 considered a similar action of the registering authority and by its order, dated 08.09.2010, observed that in W.P.No.6016 of 2010, this Court held that the mere classification of land as Assessed Waste and the entry in the revenue record that it belongs to the Government do not determine the title and that the Registrar cannot ignore ownership of the party by giving weight to mere entries in the revenue record.  
In the instant case, the petitioner has traced the legal title through the document as far back as 21.5.1918 and enumerated the details relating to as many as 12 transitions through registered sale deeds commencing from 21.05.1918 up to 12.03.1995. 
In the face of this overwhelming documentary evidence showing that the property is a private property which changed hands through registered sale deeds on as many as 12 occasions, there is no justification for respondent No.3 to place reliance on the entry in the revenue record describing the property as Assessed Waste and refusing to receive and register the document on that basis.
        For the above mentioned reasons, the Writ Petition is allowed and respondent No.3 is directed to receive the document that may be presented by the petitioner in respect of Ac.2-16 cents in Sy.No.169 of Proddatur Village and Mandal, Y.S.R.Kadapa District, and register the same, subject to the petitioner complying with the provisions of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and the Registration Act, 1908.
          As a sequel to disposal of the Writ Petition, W.P.M.P.No.435 of 2013 filed by the petitioner for interim relief is disposed of as infructuous.
                                                    ____________________________
 JUSTICE C.V.NAGARJUNA REDDY
                             

Dated 04.01.2013

DR/Vvr