About Me

My photo
since 1985 practicing as advocate in both civil & criminal laws. This blog is only for information but not for legal opinions

Sunday, March 10, 2013

proper multiplier applicable is 15 - As per the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma v. DTC[1], the proper multiplier to be applied for a person aged 40 years is 15. Thus, the total loss of earnings comes to Rs.6,000/- X 15 =Rs.90,000/-. The 1st claimant is also entitled to Rs.10,000/- towards loss of consortium.


THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B. SESHASAYANA REDDY

 

Civil Revision Petition No.2545 of 2012

 

Date:04th October, 2012

 

Between:

Gavara Suryavathi W/o.late Ramakrishna & Ors.
                ... Petitioners
a n d
Guntakala Brahma Reddy S/o.Punna Reddy & Ors.
… Respondents

***




THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B. SESHASAYANA REDDY

 

Civil Revision Petition No.2545 of 2012


ORDER:

Dis-satisfied with the quantum of compensation granted in O.P.No.319 of 1991 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-District Judge, West Godavari District, Eluru, (for short, ‘the Tribunal’), the claimants have filed this Civil Revision Petition.

2.     Facts in brief are: The petitioners are the claimants in O.P.No.319 of 1991.  Claimant No.1 is the wife; Claimant Nos.2 to 5 are children and Claimant No.6 is the mother of Gavara Ramakrisha.  He was travelling in a mini lorry bearing No.ACI 3141 along with coconut load on 19.12.1990.  At about 7.00 P.M., on reaching Kondalamma temple near Kurellagudem, a lorry bearing No.AAK 3895 dashed the mini lorry bearing No.ACI 3141 from behind.  As a result, he fell down and met with instantaneous death.  He was doing coconut business, earning Rs.1,500/- p.m. He was contributing his earnings to the maintenance of his family comprising his wife, children and mother.  He was aged about 40 years as on the date of his death.   The claimants filed OP No.319 of 1991 claiming compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- against the owners, drivers and insurers of both the vehicles involved in the accident.  The 3rd respondent-insurer of the lorry bearing No.AAK 3895 filed counter resisting the claim of the claimants.  The respondents 1 and 2-driver and owner of the lorry bearing No.AAK 3895 remained ex parte.  The 6th respondent-insurer of the mini lorry bearing No.AIC 3141 filed counter resisting the claim of the claimants.  The respondents 4 and 5-driver and owner of the said mini lorry adopted the counter of the 6th respondent-insurer.

3.     The Tribunal framed the following issues for trial:
1)     Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the lorry bearing No.AAK 3895 by its driver-1st respondent?
2)     Whether the petitioners are entitled to claim any compensation? If so, to what amount and against which of the respondents?
3)     To what relief?

On behalf of the claimants, two witnesses were examined as PWs.1 and 2 and three documents were marked as Exs.A1 to A3.  On behalf of the 6threspondent-insurer of mini lorry bearing No.AIC 3141, one witness was examined as RW.1 and one document was marked as Ex.B1.  The Tribunal, on considering the evidence brought on record and on hearing the counsel appearing for the parties, held that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the lorry bearing No.AAK 3895 and thereby proceeded to grant Rs.92,000/- towards compensation to the claimants, by an order, dated 16.01.1995.  The Tribunal dismissed the O.P. against the respondents 4 to 6.  Dis-satisfied with the quantum of compensation, the claimants have filed this revision.

3.     Though the 3rd respondent-insurer entered appearance through a counsel, none appears on their behalf when the revision came up for consideration.

4.     Heard learned counsel appearing for the petitioners/claimants and perused the material brought on record.

5.     The only contention advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners/claimants is that the Tribunal has not taken the proper multiplier for arriving the loss of contribution to the claimants.  According to the learned counsel, the proper multiplier applicable is 15, whereas the Tribunal has taken the multiplier No.12.  As per the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma v. DTC[1], the proper multiplier to be applied for a person aged 40 years is 15.  Thus, the total loss of earnings comes to Rs.6,000/- X 15 =Rs.90,000/-.  The 1st claimant is also entitled to Rs.10,000/- towards loss of consortium.  The amount claimed by the petitioners/claimants is Rs.1,00,000/-. The Tribunal granted compensation of Rs.92,000/-.  In that view of the matter, I am inclined to enhance the compensation allowed to the petitioners/claimants from Rs.92,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/-. 

6.     Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed enhancing the compensation allowed to the petitioners/claimants from Rs.92,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/-.  The enhanced compensation amount of Rs.8,000/- shall carry interest at the rate of 6% p.a. from the date of petition till the date of payment.  No costs.

_________________________

B. SESHASAYANA REDDY, J.

Date:04th October, 2012.

cs

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B. SESHASAYANA REDDY

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Civil Revision Petition No.2545 of 2012



Date:04th October, 2012




[1] (2009) 6 SCC 121

Saturday, March 9, 2013

Order IX Rule 9 of C.P.C. = Therefore, it is quite clear that having made an order in the petition under Section 5 of the Limitation Act final, the discretion exercised by the Court below in restoring the suit cannot be again re-agitated. So far as the grievance with regard to non-imposition of costs is concerned, in fact there are two limbs under Order IX Rule 9 of C.P.C., and the Court has a discretion to set aside the dismissal order if sufficient cause is shown for non-appearance and such a setting aside would be subject to such terms as to the costs or otherwise, as it thinks fit.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT HYDERABAD

 


MONDAY, THE NINETEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN

 

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE N.R.L.NAGESWARA RAO

 

CIVIL REVISION PETITION No. 605 of 2013

 

Between:

 

Kotikelapudi Balasarada Kumari                                 ..... PETITIONER

AND

 

M/s Kings Enterprises, a registered partnership,
Rep. by its Managing Partner Vegesle Narayana Raju
and three others.                                                    .....RESPONDENTS




















The Court made the following:

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE N.R.L.NAGESWARA RAO

 

CIVIL REVISION PETITION No. 605 of 2013

ORDER:

The Civil Revision Petition is filed against the order in I.A.No.1245 of 2010 in O.S.No.11 of 2003 on the file of the I Additional District Judge, Vizianagaram. 
2.       The revision petitioner is defendant in the suit and the above said application was filed Under Order IX Rule 9 C.P.C., to set aside the default order dated 25.06.2008 and the Court below after considering the reasons mentioned, allowed the application.  Aggrieved by the said order the present revision is filed. 
3.       As can be seen from the record, the counsel for the Revision Petitioner contends that the provisions of the Order IX Rule 9 C.P.C., have not been complied with, since there was no order as to costs and there is no sufficient reason to restore the suit.  Further, it is his contention that after the dismissal of the suit, some third party interests have been created and the cause of action does not survive. So far as the later contention is concerned, it is a matter, which has to be decided by the Court during the trial.  So far as the grounds for setting aside the dismissal order is concerned, the Court has already condoned the delay of 38 days in I.A.No.2644 of 2008 accepting the reasons given by the plaintiffs and on the same cause, the suit has been restored.  Therefore, it is quite clear that having made an order in the petition under Section 5 of the Limitation Act final, the discretion exercised by the Court below in restoring the suit cannot be again re-agitated.  So far as the grievance with regard to non-imposition of costs is concerned, in fact there are two limbs under Order IX Rule 9 of C.P.C., and the Court has a discretion to set aside the dismissal order if sufficient cause is shown for 
non-appearance and such a setting aside would be subject to such terms as to the costs or otherwise, as it thinks fit. 
 Therefore, I am not able to accept the contention of the counsel for the revision petitioner that imposition of the costs is mandatory before an order of restoration is made under Order IX Rule 9 of C.P.C.  On the other hand, if sufficient cause is shown, it is mandatory to set aside the dismissal order on such terms as to costs or otherwise.  In this case the Court below has imposed conditions about the trial of the suit and also for filing of the list of witnesses.  Therefore, I do not find any infirmity in the order of the lower Court for non-imposition of the costs in restoring the suit.  But however, the counsel for the revision petitioner represents that prior to the dismissal, costs were imposed against the plaintiff and those costs were also not paid.   I feel, in the interest of justice, if the earlier costs which were already imposed should have been directed to be paid by the plaintiffs.  
Therefore, in view of the above circumstances, the lower court is directed to see that the costs, if any, imposed prior to restoration of suit shall be paid before the commencement of the trial as per the orders of the Court.
Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is disposed of.  Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this revision shall stand disposed of.  No order as to costs.

________________________
N.R.L.NAGESWARA RAO,J
Date: 19.02.2013
SSV/KVS

 

 

temporary injunction= for partition and separate possession of the suit schedule property. In the said suit, the petitioner filed I.A. No.47 of 2012 for temporary injunction restraining the respondent from alienating the suit schedule property pending the suit. The trial Court has granted injunction- By order, dated 07-01-2013, the learned District Judge, Anantapur allowed the said C.M.A. and set aside the order of injunction.- the school records produced by him do not show that he is the adopted son of Pedda Bandeppa, and that therefore, he failed to establish his prima-facie case. - Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, which contains the doctrine of lis pendens and held that even in the absence of injunction, the interests of the petitioner are secured.

CRP 462 / 2013

CRPSR 2610 / 2013
PETITIONERRESPONDENT
K. VEERESH, ANANTHAPUR DIST  VSK. SIDDA LINGAMMA, ANANTHAPUR DIST
PET.ADV. : SRINIVASRESP.ADV. : 
SUBJECT: ARTICLE 227DISTRICT:  ANANTAPUR



The Hon’ble Sri Justice C.V. Nagarjuna Reddy


Civil Revision Petition No. 462 of 2013

Date: 21-02-2013

Between:

K. Veeresh                                                              .. Petitioner

And

K. Sidda Lingamma                                              .. Respondent



Counsel for the petitioner      :  Mr. K. Srinivas

Counsel for the respondent       :  ---











The Court made the following:




















ORDER:

This Civil Revision Petition arises out of order, dated
07-01-2013, in C.M.A. No. 23 of 2012 on the file of the learned District Judge, Anantapur.

  The petitioner herein has filed O.S. No. 45 of 2012 in the court of the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Anantapur for partition and separate possession of the suit schedule property.  In the said suit, the petitioner filed I.A. No.47 of 2012 for temporary injunction restraining the respondent from alienating the suit schedule property pending the suit.  The trial Court has granted injunction.  Assailing the same, the respondent herein filed C.M.A. No. 23 of 2012 in the Court of the learned District Judge, Anantapur.  By order, dated 07-01-2013, the learned District Judge, Anantapur allowed the said C.M.A. and set aside the order of injunction.
I have heard Mr. K. Srinivas, the learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the record.
 In his order, the learned District Judge has discussed the prima-facie case of the petitioner and found that the school records produced by him do not show that he is the adopted son of Pedda Bandeppa, and that therefore, he failed to establish his prima-facie case.  The learned District Judge has also referred to Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, which contains the doctrine of lis pendens and held that even in the absence of injunction, the interests of the petitioner are secured.  Having carefully considered the reasoning of the learned District Judge,
I am convinced that the order under revision does not suffer from any jurisdictional error requiring interference of this Court in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.  The Civil Revision Petition is accordingly dismissed.

As a sequel to dismissal of the revision petition, C.R.P.M.P. No.603 of 2013 filed by the petitioner for interim relief is disposed of as infructuous.

                                                              _____________________

                                                   C.V.NAGARJUNA REDDY, J

February 21, 2013.
Mgr/Am

injunction suit not maintainable with out possession = In a suit for injunction, what becomes material is the state of affairs obtaining as on the date of filing of the suit. Though the appellant pleaded that she is in possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule property, in the course of cross-examination, she admitted that DW.1 is in possession of the property, not only by the time the suit was filed, but also 9 years prior to her deposition. That itself is sufficient to non-suit the appellant. No substantial question of law arises for consideration in this second appeal.

SA 94 / 2013



PETITIONERRESPONDENT
CHEMBETI LAKSHMAMMA W/O PERUMALLU  VSCHERI SUBBAIAH AND 3 OTHERS
PET.ADV. : SUBRAHMANYA NARUSURESP.ADV. : 
SUBJECT: nullDISTRICT:  CHITTOOR



 THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L.NARASIMHA REDDY

Second Appeal No.94 of 2013
JUDGMENT:

The appellant filed O.S.No.700 of 1980 in the Court of I Additional District Munsif, Tirupathi, for the relief of perpetual injunction, in respect of the suit schedule property.  
She stated that she is in possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule property and that the respondents are trying to interfere with her possession without any basis.  The trial Court dismissed the suit through its judgment, dated 08.08.1988.  
Aggrieved by that, the appellant filed A.S.No.107 of 1988 in the Court of III Additional District Judge, Tirupathi.  
The appeal was dismissed through judgment, dated 14.08.1996.  Hence, the second appeal.
Heard Sri K.S.R.Murthy, the learned counsel for the appellant.
The appeal was initially presented way back in the year 1996.  Ever since then, it has been undergoing several adjournments and stages, on one ground or the other.  It was in the recent past that the second appeal has been numbered. 
On the basis of the pleadings before it, the trial Court framed the following issues:

1.                              “Whether Cheri Perumallu was absolute owner of the suit schedule and it devolved on the plaintiff due to intestate demise of cheri Perumallu?
2.                              Whether the 2nd defendant purchased the suit schedule from 1st defendant and enjoying it as its absolute owner?
3.                              Whether the 2nd defendant is not a necessary party to the suit?
4.                              Whether the cause of action alleged in the suit is true and genuine?
5.                              To what relief?”

On behalf of the appellant, PWs.1 to 4 were examined and Exs.A.1 to A.20 were filed.  On behalf of the defendants, DWs.1 to 4 were examined and Exs.B.1 to B.52 were filed.  The trial Court held all the issues against the appellant.  The lower Appellate Court framed the following points for its consideration, and held the same against the appellant.

1.                                   “Whether the plaintiff has title to the 1st item of the plaint schedule?
2.                                   Whether the plaintiff has possession in respect of 1st  item of the plaint schedule?
3.                                   Whether the plaintiff has title to the 2nd item of the plaint schedule?
4.                                   Whether the plaintiff has possession in respect of 2nd item of the plaint schedule?
5.                                   Whether the plaintiff is entitled for permanent injunction in respect of items 1 and 2 of the plaint schedule?
6.                                   Whether the judgment and decree of the trial Court are liable to be set aside?”


In a suit for injunction, what becomes material is the state of affairs obtaining as on the date of filing of the suit.  Though the appellant pleaded that she is in possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule property, in the course of cross-examination, she admitted that DW.1 is in possession of the property, not only by the time the suit was filed, but also 9 years prior to her deposition.  That itself is sufficient to non-suit the appellant.  No substantial question of law arises for consideration in this second appeal.
Hence, the second appeal is dismissed.  There shall be no order as to costs.
The miscellaneous petition filed in this second appeal shall also stand disposed of.

____________________
L.NARASIMHA REDDY, J.   
Dated:11.02.2013

GJ











THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L.NARASIMHA REDDY

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Writ Petition No.4053 of 2013



Date:11.02.2013

GJ                                                                     




offences under sections 143, 147, 447, 427, 324, 504, 506 and 353 read with 149 of IPC and section 4 of the A.P. Medicare service (Damage to property) Act, 2008.= The names of the petitioners find place in First Information Report as the persons responsible for causing injuries to LW.6-Kumari Vandera Jyothi and damaging the equipment in the hospital. Such is the accusation levelled against the petitioners, they do not deserve for grant of anticipatory bail.


HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE B. SESHASAYANA REDDY
Criminal Petition No.1292 of 2013

O R D E R:-

          The petitioners are A.1 to A-3 in Cr.No.115 of 2012 of Narayanpet Police Station, Mahabubnagar District, registered for the offences under sections 143, 147, 447, 427, 324, 504, 506 and 353 read with 149 of IPC and section 4 of the A.P. Medicare service (Damage to property) Act, 2008.
          The accusation made against the petitioners is that they, along with other accused, attacked the staff of Raghavendra Nursing Home and caused bleeding injuries to LW.6-Kumari Vandera Jyothi, apart from damaging the hospital equipment, on the ground that Boya Narsimulu was not given treatment promptly.
Heard learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners and learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondent-State.
          It is contended by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that the petitioners are innocent of the offences with which they are accused of and therefore they deserve for grant of anticipatory bail.
          Learned Additional Public Prosecutor opposed application on the ground that investigation is pending and the names of the petitioners find place in the First Information Report as the persons responsible for causing bleeding injuries to LW.6-Kumari Vandera Jyothi and damaging the hospital equipment and therefore they do not deserve for grant of anticipatory bail.
          I have gone through the remand case diary dated 21.01.2013, copy of which finds place at Page No.6 of the material papers.  The names of the petitioners find place in First Information Report as the persons responsible for causing injuries to LW.6-Kumari Vandera Jyothi and damaging the equipment in the hospital.  Such is the accusation levelled against the petitioners, they do not deserve for grant of anticipatory bail.
          Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is dismissed.


_________________________
B. Seshasayana Reddy, J
25th February, 2013.
Sr/vjl

                         

                         


HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE B. SESHASAYANA REDDY

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

                         

Criminal Petition No.1292 of 2013

                         


                         

                         

                         

                         

                        sr/vjl                             February 25, 2013